CC BY-NC-ND
0Accepted Manuscript
Title: Role of Computed tomography in predicting prognosis of Hepatic portal venous gas
Author: Makram Moussa Ines Marzouk Kais Abdelmoula Amira Manamani Nadida Dali Leila Charrada Ben Farhat Lotfi hendaoui
PII: DOI:
Reference:
S2210-2612(16)30533-8 http://dx.doi.Org/doi:10.1016/j.ijscr.2016.11.055 IJSCR 2291
To appear in:
Received date: Accepted date:
7-11-2016 28-11-2016
Please cite this article as: MoussaMakram, Marzouk Inès, Abdelmoula Kais, Manamani Amira, Dali Nadida, Farhat Leila Charrada Ben, hendaoui Lotfi.Role of Computed tomography in predicting prognosis of Hepatic portal venous gas..International Journal of Surgery Case Reports http://dx.doi.org/10.1016Zj.ijscr.2016.11.055
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Role of Computed tomography in predicting prognosis of Hepatic portal venous gas
Makram Moussa1, Inès Marzouk 2, Kais Abdelmoula2, Amira Manamani2,Nadida Dali2, , Leila Charrada Ben Farhat2, Lotfi hendaoui2.
1. Department of surgery, University hospital of Bizerta Tunisia
2. Department of diagnostic and interventional radiology , University hospital Mongi Slim Marsa TUNISIA
Corresponding author
Makram moussa
Medical School Of Tunis, University Of Manar
Department of surgery, University hospital Bougatfa Bizerta TUNISIA Mail: makrammoussa@yahoo.fr Tel : +216 53536699
HIGHLIGHTS:
• When hepatic portal venous gas is diagnosed on computed tomography, the first etiology that radiologist should look for is the intestinal necrosis.
• The association of hepatic portal venous gas and pneumatosis intestinalis is highly suggestive of acute mesenteric ischemia.
• Abundance of hepatic portal venous gas on CT is not correlated with prognosis.
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to report through 13 cases the particularities of abdominal computed tomography (CT) aspects of hepatic portal venous gas (HPVG) and its correlation with patient prognosis.
METHODS: We analyzed abundance of HPVG and its association with pneumatosis intestinalis (PI) in correlation with fatal outcome using chi-square tests.
RESULTS: Etiologies were mesenteric infarction (n=5), sigmoid diverticulitis (n=1), septic shock (n=1), postoperative peritonitis (n=1), acute pancreatitis (n=1), iatrogenic cause (n=3) and idiopathic after a laparotomy (n=1). The outcome was fatal in for 6 patients. Abundance of HPV was expressed in total number of hepatic segments involved. The involvement of 3 or more segments was a sensitive sign for lethal outcome with high sensitivity (100%) but it was not specific (50%). Negative predictive value of this sign was 100% (p <0,005). Positive predictive value of PI for death was 100% (p <0,001).
DISCUSSION: Abundance of HPVG is correlated with prognosis. The presence of PI announces poor outcome Negative predictive value of presence of HPVG in 3 or more segments is interesting. Predicting prognosis with CT can help surgeons to assess the most adequate treatment. Iatrogenic causes are increasingly described after interventional radiology procedures with favorable course.
CONCLUSION: The first etiology radiologists should look for in front of HPVG involving more than 3 hepatic segments and associated with PI is intestinal necrosis which announces a poor prognosis. This study shows that outside of shock situations, HPVG involving 2 or less hepatic segments without PI predicts a good outcome.
Keywords: portal vein;gas;acute mesenteric ischemia; Diverticulitis; computed tomography; surgery.
INTRODUCTION
Hepatic portal venous gas (HPVG) is a rare radiological sign, defined by the presence of gas in the portal system. This sign is most often associated with extensive intestinal necrosis. In some cases HPVG can be associated with benign etiologies. Unnecessary exploratory laparotomy should be avoided in these conditions. Nowadays, HVPG is much more easily detected through the routine use of ultrasound and computed tomography (CT). In this cases series, we review the CT manifestations
of HPVG and their causes in 13 adults. We focused on the correlation between characteristics of HPVG appearance on CT, etiology and patient prognosis.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
The medical records of 13 patients with HPVG or mesenteric venous gas were selected. Seven cases collected over a period of 7 years from January 2008 to January 2015 retrospectively reviewed through the Picture Archiving And Communicating System (PACS) of the radiology department of Mongi Slim university hospital. The search key words were "portal venous gas", "mesenteric ischemia", mesenteric infarct", "pneumatosis intestinalis". Six other cases were prospectively included from two centers (Marsa and Bizerta).
Two scan machines were used. A monoslice SOMATOM plus 4 (Siemens Medical System, Erlanger, Germany) was used from January 2008 to March 2012. A multislice Aquilion 64 (Toshiba medical Systems, Otawara, Japan) was used for the period going from April 2012 to March 2016. Helical CT scans were performed before and after intravenous contrast agent administration using a power injector (80 to 120 at a rate of 4 ml/s with 35 seconds scan delay for the arterial phase and 70 to 80 seconds for the portal phase). The following scanning parameters were used: thickness 1 mm, reconstruction interval 1 mm.
CT scans and medical records were reviewed. We recorded for each patient the clinical signs available on medical file; we reviewed on CT DICOM images the extension of the HPVG in the liver. The number of involved segments > to 3 and the presence of pneumatosis intestinalis (PI) were also analyzed in correlation with fatal outcome of patients.
The chi-square tests were used to make comparisons and an a priori statistical level of significance of p value < 0.01 was used to adjust for multiple comparisons.
RESULTS
The clinical histories, imaging features and outcomes are summarized in the table (table 1).
Patients, 5 males and 6 females, were aged 68.9 on average (range 43-82 years). They were hospitalized in cardiology, general surgery and intensive care departments.
In our series, abdominal CT scan was performed on the basis of diffuse abdominal pain in 5 cases. In the other patients, it was indicated by septic shock with abdominal distension and by abdominal tense with fever after surgery, and following an attempt of external biliary drainage, hepatic mass biopsy and percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of hepatocellular carcinoma in one case each.
Positive diagnosis of HVPG was established in the 100% of cases by abdominal CT independently of the protocol. The extension of HPVG was correlated with the number of hepatic segments involved. The left lobe was involved in 10 cases. Three or more segments were involved by HPVG in 10 cases with fatal outcome in 6 cases. The right lobe was exclusively involved in 2 cases caused by iatrogenic and idiopathic etiologies. PI was exclusively observed with mesenteric infarction (n=3) and was associated with a lethal outcome.
The etiology of HPVG was determined on the basis of CT findings in 12 cases. Acute mesenteric ischemia five patients (38%) with (AMI) (figure 1). Two cases were related to a septic context (15%). The iatrogenic context was observed in 3 cases (23%) (figure 2). In one case (case 8) with serum amylase and lipase levels at 5 times normal, CT scan showed necrotic pancreatitis with multiple fluid collections (figure 3). In one case (case 9), the HPVG was located in the left lobe and was associated with a colonic diverticulitis. In one case (case 5), the HPVG was observed in small quantities in the left lobe (figure 4) and CT scan didn't show any extra sign suggestive of a gastrointestinal tract condition.
Four patients underwent surgery with 2 death complications in the postoperative course of a mesenteric infarction and peritonitis. In three other cases, death was observed within 2 hours in 2 cases of extended mesenteric infarction and on day 2 after a necrotic pancreatitis (figure 4). The Clinical and radiological monitoring by X-ray and abdominal CT was considered to confirm the diagnosis in the other patients.
The involvement of 3 or more segments was a sensitive sign for lethal outcome with high sensitivity (100%) but it was not specific (50%). Negative predictive value of this sign was 100% (p <0,005).
The sensitivity of PI for death was about 66.67% and the specificity 100%. Positive predicting value of this sign was 100% (p <0,001).
DISCUSSION
HPVG indicates the presence of gas in the portal vein and its branches. It was historically associated with a poor prognosis with a mortality rate estimated between 84 and 90% [1,2]. More recently reported mortality rates in the literature put it in the range of 27-47% [3,4]. Better prognosis of the HPVG is linked to the development of radiological cross sectional techniques especially the CT allowing detecting of small quantities. In our series, the mortality rate reached 46 %; four patients died after an extensive mesenteric infarction, one patient after an acute severe pancreatitis and one during a reoperation for postoperative peritonitis for anastomotic leakage.
CT is efficient; it's now considered the imaging tool of choice for the diagnosis of HPVG. HPVG occurs usually in elderly patients with co-morbidities and radiologists face often a contraindication to administrate iodinated contrast because of an underlying renal insufficiency. The pre-contrast phase is sufficient to detect HPVG and it can be the only acquisition to perform. The enhanced CT with a single-phase (portal) or with biphasic acquisition (arterial and portal) is very helpful for the etiological diagnosis. Complementary lung window is recommended for the identification of gas because of its higher sensitivity of detection of small quantities of gas [1,3]. The main differential diagnosis remains pneumobilia which is defined by the presence of air in the bile ducts. It is mainly located in the central part of the liver and situated to more than 2 cm from the hepatic capsule [5,6] unlike HPVG which can reach the periphery. In some cases, pneumobilia and HPVG may coexist depending on the etiology.
The appearance of the gas in the portal system may result from intestinal mucosal injury, increased intraluminal pressure in the digestive tract or sepsis [5,6].Intravascular gas is most commonly found in the portal trunk [7]. The left lobe of the liver is predisposed to develop HPVG, possibly because of peculiarities in hepatic venous anatomy [6]. In our series left lobe was involved in 9 cases. According to many authors reported that there is no relationship between the extension of the HPVG and the
prognosis of the underlying disease [4,8,9]. However, Heye and al [8] showed that the distribution of gas at certain anatomical locations in the porto-mesenteric venous system, namely the arcade and segmental vessels, achieved a better diagnostic performance in detecting ischemic etiology. When gas distribution is limited to segmental portal branches; it's linked to a better prognosis with a high frequency of non ischemic etiologies. In our study the involvement of 3 or more segments was correlated to poor prognosis in 75% of cases. High negative predictive value of this sign suggests that HPVG identified in 2 or less hepatic segments without any clinical severity evidence could avoid surgery for the patient. Seak and coll [2] raised the correlation of the association of shock and PI with high rate of mortality. In our series the association of PI with HPVG was correlated to fatal course in 100% of cases.
Five etiologies were represented in our case series. In the literature, the most dangerous and the most common one is the acute mesenteric ischemia (AMI) (70%) accompanied by a mortality of around 80 % [10]. In case of a high level of suspicion of AMI, a biphasic (arterial and portal) mesenteric multi-detector CT angiography should be performed because of its high sensitivity and specificity [10-12]. On CT, direct signs of AMI are the abrupt termination of the vessel or the filling defects in the vessel lumen. Bani Hani and coll [13] found in their study that CT findings suggestive of ischemic PI and HPVG, did not diagnose AMI accurately enough to reliably identify patients needing operation. Associated signs such as bowel dilation, wall thickening, attenuation, fat standing and ascites should be investigated on CT [14].
Other surgical etiologies include infectious causes, in particular, sigmoid diverticulitis, acute cholecystitis and acute appendicitis.
HPVG is a rare complication of diverticulitis [15] which is the second most frequently reported cause[16].Associated highly suggestive signs are colonic diverticulosis, fat standing or abscess in contact with colon wall thickening. Intra-venous antibiotic treatment is recommended even if HPVG is present on CT [9]. In case of non improvement, surgery must be performed.
Iatrogenic HPVG has been reported and mostly occurs in the course of retrograde endoscopic cholangio-pancreatography [17], during colonoscopy [18] or after barium enema [19,20]. In our series, HPVG was detected on control CT after external biliary drainage in one case, after percutaneous drainage and biopsy of a septic and necrotic hepatic mass in another case and after a percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of a hepato cellular carcinoma in a third case. After antibiotic treatment under clinical monitoring with short hospitalization, the post-operative courses were uneventful for all three patients.
There are other even rarer causes of HPVG such as gastrointestinal cancers [15,21,22], inflammatory diseases such as crohn's disease and acute pancreatitis[15,18,23,24]. Abdominal trauma has been described as a possible cause of HPVG [25,26]. However, benign cases of HPVG have been reported [27]. This entity does not require any surgical treatment and has a good clinical outcome. In some cases, the etiology remains unknown and may require laparoscopic investigation [28]. In our series, a small quantity of HPVG was distributed in the distal vessels of both segments VII and VIII of the right lobe in one case (case 5) without any extra CT sign. Surgery was performed only because of a high level of suspicion of AMI in a 72 year-old man with acute diffuse abdominal pain. Laparoscopic surgery allowed us to rule out all cited etiologies of HPVG.
CONCLUSION
HPVG is rarely observed in imaging. The first diagnosis that radiologists should look for before discussing other etiologies is the intestinal necrosis due to its severe prognosis and the need for emergency surgery. Multi phased enhanced CT is helpful for the etiological diagnosis of HPVG with high sensitivity and specificity. Outside of shock situations, HPVG involving 2 or less hepatic segments without PI could avoid emergency surgery. Once the AMI is excluded, etiological investigation must be oriented by the clinical signs. If any doubt remains on ischemic origin, laparoscopy or laparotomy should then be undertaken.
Author contribution
We certify that we have participated sufficiently in the intellectual content, conception and design of this work or the analysis and interpretation of the data, as well as the writing of the manuscript, to take public responsibility for it and have agreed to have our name listed as a contributor.
1. Makram moussa Study concept and design, Drafting of the manuscript
6. L.Charrada-Ben Farhat Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content
7. L.hendaoui Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content No source have funded our case report
Ethical Approval
All the figures are anonymized for the case series. Our work is in accordance with medical ethics
i. Acquisition of the data
2. Ines marzouk
3. K.Abdelmoula
4. A.Manamani
5. Nadida dali
Drafting of the manuscript, correcting Analysis and interpretation of the data, Study supervision Acquisition of the data (CT)
Conflict of Interest: all authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
REFERENCES
1. Faberman RS, Mayo-Smith WW. Outcome of 17 patients with portal venous gas detected by CT. Am J Roentgenol. 1997 Dec 1;169(6):1535-8.
2. Seak C-J, Hsu K-H, Wong Y-C et al. The prognostic factors of adult patients with hepatic portal venous gas in the ED. Am J Emerg Med. 2014 Sep;32(9):972-5.
3. Schindera ST, Triller J, Vock P, et al. Detection of hepatic portal venous gas: its clinical impact and outcome. Emerg Radiol. 2006 Mar 18;12(4):164-70.
4. Monneuse O, Pilleul F, Barth X et al. Portal Venous Gas Detected on Computed Tomography in Emergency Situations: Surgery Is Still Necessary. World J Surg. 2007 Apr 5;31(5):1066-72.
5. Peloponissios N, Halkic N, Pugnale M, et al. Hepatic portal gas in adults: Review of the literature and presentation of a consecutive series of 11 cases. Arch Surg. 2003 Dec 1;138(12):1367-70.
6. Sebastia C, Quiroga S, Espin E, et al. Portomesenteric Vein Gas: Pathologic Mechanisms, CT Findings, and Prognosis. RadioGraphics. 2000 Sep 1;20(5):1213-24.
7. Lassandro F, Scaglione M, Rossi G, et al. Portomesenteric vein gas: diagnostic and prognostic value. Emerg Radiol. 2014 Feb 1;9(2):96-9.
8. Heye T, Bernhard M, Mehrabi A, et al. Portomesenteric venous gas: Is gas distribution linked to etiology and outcome? Eur J Radiol. 2012 Dec;81(12):3862-9.
9. Hou S-K, Chern C-H, How C-K, et al. Hepatic portal venous gas: clinical significance of computed tomography findings. Am J Emerg Med. 2004 May;22(3):214-8.
10. Oldenburg W, Lau L, Rodenberg TJ, et al. Acute mesenteric ischemia: A clinical review. Arch Intern Med. 2004 May 24;164(10):1054-62.
11. Aschoff AJ, Stuber G, Becker BW et al. et al. Evaluation of acute mesenteric ischemia: accuracy of biphasic mesenteric multi-detector CT angiography. Abdom Imaging. 2008 Apr 19;34(3):345-57.
12. Barmase M, Kang M, Wig J, et al. Role of multidetector CT angiography in the evaluation of suspected mesenteric ischemia. Eur J Radiol. 2011 Dec;80(3):e582-7.
13. Bani Hani M, Kamangar F, Goldberg S, et al. Pneumatosis and portal venous gas: do CT findings reassure? J Surg Res. 2013 Dec;185(2):581-6.
14. Wasnik A, Kaza RK, Al-Hawary MM, et al. Multidetector CT imaging in mesenteric ischemia-pearls and pitfalls. Emerg Radiol. 2010 Dec 4;18(2):145-56.
15. Abboud B, El Hachem J, Yazbeck T, et al. Hepatic portal venous gas: Physiopathology, etiology, prognosis and treatment. World J Gastroenterol WJG. 2009 Aug 7;15(29):3585-90.
16. Sellner F, Sobhian B, Baur M, et al. Intermittent hepatic portal vein gas complicating diverticulitis—a case report and literature review. Int J Colorectal Dis. 2007 Jul 19;22(11):1395-9.
17. Bisceglia M, Simeone A, Forlano R, et al. Fatal Systemic Venous Air Embolism During Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopancreatography: Adv Anat Pathol. 2009 Jul;16(4):255-62.
18. Ma ASC, Ewing I, Murray CD, et al. Hepatic portal venous gas and portal venous thrombosis following colonoscopy in a patient with terminal ileal Crohn's disease. BMJ Case Rep. 2015 May 4;2015:bcr2014206854.
19. Karaosmanoglu D, Oktar SO, Araç M, et al. Portal and systemic venous gas in a patient after lumbar puncture. Br J Radiol. 2005 Aug 1;78(932):767-9.
20. Lee CG, Kang HW, Song MK, et al. A Case of Hepatic Portal Venous Gas as a Complication of Endoscopic Balloon Dilatation. J Korean Med Sci. 2011;26(8):1108.
21. A N, H I, H I, et al. Portal venous gas associated with splenic abscess secondary to colon cancer. Anticancer Res. 1998 Dec;19(6C):5641-4.
22. Nelson AL, Millington TM, Sahani D, et al. Hepatic portal venous gas: The abcs of management. Arch Surg. 2009 Jun 1;144(6):575-81.
23. Hc P, Ws L, Sy J, et al. [Hepatic portal venous gas associated with acute pancreatitis: reports of two cases and review of literature]. Korean J Gastroenterol Taehan Sohwagi Hakhoe Chi. 2007 Aug;50(2):131-5.
24. Lim JW, Kim K-J, Ye BD, et al. Enterovenous fistulization: a rare complication of Crohn's disease. World J Gastroenterol WJG. 2011 Dec 21;17(47):5227-30.
25. Brown MA, Hauschildt JP, Casola G, et al. Intravascular Gas as an Incidental Finding at US after Blunt Abdominal Trauma. Radiology. 1999 Feb 1;210(2):405-8.
26. Pear BL, Evitts MP. Portal venous gas subsequent to blunt abdominal trauma. Emerg Radiol. 1999 Nov;6(5):310-2.
27. Ho LM, Paulson EK, Thompson WM. Pneumatosis Intestinalis in the Adult: Benign to Life-Threatening Causes. Am J Roentgenol. 2007 Jun 1;188(6):1604-13.
28. Kearns K, Tran Van D, Alberti N, et al. L'aéroportie : bloc ou pas bloc ? Ann Fr Anesth Réanimation. 2013 Nov;32(11):803-6.
FIGURES caption
Figure 1: 72 years-old male with atrial fibrillation, Diffuse abdominal pain, a: pneumoperitoneum (black arrow), HPVG (black bold arrow) b: Superior mesenteric artery occluded (bold white arrow) c and a: pneumatosis intestinalis (white arrows)
Figure 2: CT after an external biliary drainage in a 69 year-old woman followed for cholangiocarcinoma (case 4).Left portal branches venous gas (a and b :white arrows), Dilated Intrahepatic bile ducts pacified with contrast(b, black arrow).
Figure 3: unenhanced CT scans showing small quantities of HPVG (case5). No etiology was discussed on CT even after the laparotomy. Idiopathic HPVG was concluded after spontaneous resolution of the abdominal pain.
Figure 4: axial CT scans: HPVG (bold arrow) complicating a necrotizing pancreatitis (case 8). Heterogeneous enhancing of the liver and the pancreas with multiple fluid effusions (black arrows) and mesenteric vein gas (white arrow)
Table caption
Table 1: summary of the clinical history, imaging features and outcomes for all 13 cases of the study
Table 1 : summary of the clinical history, imaging features and outcomes for all 11 cases of the study
Age gender
Clinical Symptoms
CT protocol
associated CT Signs
Surgery
etiology
75 y male
78 y female
73 y male
69 y female
Diffuse abdominal pain in a patient with atrial fibrillation
septic shock
Postoperative course of a colonic tumor surgery, fever
CT after external biliary drainage.
- unenhanced
- Arterial phase
- Portal phase
- unenhanced
- Arterial phase
- Portal phase
- unenhanced
- Portal phase unenhanced
Left lobe (II III, IV)
Segment II
Left lobe (II III, IV)
Left lobe (II III, IV)
- mesenteric venous gas Yes
- Anomaly of parietal enhancement
- Occlusion of the superior mesenteric artery
- Pneumoperitoneum
- Hepatic perfusion No disorders.
- Bilateral pneumonitis.
- Multiple Yes
intraperitoneal
collections.
Contrast opacification of No
the bile ducts
pneumibilia
Acute Mesenteric infarction.
Pneumonitis.
Septic shock.
Peritonitis
Iatrogenic
72 y male 7l y female
67 y female
54 y male
Diffuse abdominal pain
circulatory collapse
Segments VII and VIII No extra signs
unenhanced
- unenhanced
- Arterial phase
- Portal phase
- unenhanced
- Arterial phase
- Portal phase
Diffuse abdominal - unenhanced pain
Diffuse abdominal pain
- Portal phase
Left lobe (II III, IV)
All the liver
All the liver
- mesenteric venous gas
- Anomaly of enhancement of intestine wall
- Perfusion liver disorders.
- mesenteric venous gas
- Anomaly enhancement of the wall of the digestive handles
- Thinning of the wall inlets.
- Obstruction of distal branches of the SMA
- Perfusion liver disorders.
- Multiple streams of necrosis, Heterogeneous enhancement of the pancreas
idiopathic
Acute Mesenteric infarction.
Acute Mesenteric infarction.
Necrotizing pancreatitis
alive death
66 y female
72yfemale
43ymale
82Y female 74Y male
Fever and pain of the left lower quadrant.
unenhanced
percutaneous drainage of a liver abscess and biopsy of a liver tumor CT at the waning of percutaneous radiofrequency ablation
Diffuse abdomominal pain, shock epigastria pain
- Portal phase -unenhanced
- Portal phase
-unenhanced - Portal phase
unenhanced - unenhanced
- Arterial phase
- Portal phase
Left lobe (II III, IV)
Left lobe (II III, IV) and segment VII
segment VIII
All the liver All the liver
Colonic diverticulosis yes with significant fat standing in front of the sigmoid diverticulum. Liver collection no
(suspected tumoral necrosis)
Sigmoid diverticulitis, alive
iatrogenic alive
Cirrhotic liver no iatrogenic alive
3 nodules treated with
radiofrequency
- PI. no
- mesenteric venous gas -Anomaly enhancement yes of the wall of the
digestive handles
- Thinning of the wall inlets.
Acute Mesenteric death
infarction.
Acute Mesenteric alive
infarction.
