Scholarly article on topic 'Heat Exchange and Separation Efficiency in a Cluster of Gas-solid Separators in a Complex Cement Production Plant'

Heat Exchange and Separation Efficiency in a Cluster of Gas-solid Separators in a Complex Cement Production Plant Academic research paper on "Materials engineering"

CC BY-NC-ND
0
0
Share paper
Academic journal
Energy Procedia
OECD Field of science
Keywords
{cyclone / "Eulerian multiphase" / "gas-solid heat exchange" / "computational fluid dynamics" / "geometrical optimization."}

Abstract of research paper on Materials engineering, author of scientific article — Francesco Risi, Claudio Poggiani

Abstract This work presents a study on a gas-solid cyclone separator used in a complex cement production plant. The main objective of the study consists on the performance evaluation and optimization of the cyclone separator in terms of particle separation and heat transfer efficiencies, while keeping pressure losses under control. The thermal interaction is between two gas-solid mixtures, one at 850°C and the other at 600°C, respectively. The solid phase consists mostly of calcium carbonate subsequently intended to the so-called baking process for the production of clinker and ultimately cement. A first model has been setup using experimental data as boundary conditions to assess the physical model behavior and the CFD solver parameters. After that, five additional models with different geometries have been analysed to evaluate the influence of the vortex finder (vf) length on the separation efficiency and on the heat exchange performance. Increasing the length of the vf, the results show a global improvement in the separation efficiency of up to 5% if compared to the geometry without the vf. Further, the increasing of the vf length determines a monotonic decrease of temperature at the exit but a monotonic increase of pressure losses. In the second part of this work, using one of the previous models with vf, a study of the influence of the particle diameter on the separation efficiency has been performed. The increaseof particle diameter causes an increase of the separation and thermal exchange performance, decreasing at the same time the pressure drop. The numerical approach for all the cases is based on implicit unsteady simulations using the Eulerian Multiphase model

Academic research paper on topic "Heat Exchange and Separation Efficiency in a Cluster of Gas-solid Separators in a Complex Cement Production Plant"

CrossMark

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect

Energy Procedía 82 (2015) 886 - 892

ATI 2015 - 70th Conference of the ATI Engineering Association

Heat exchange and separation efficiency in a cluster of gassolid separators in a complex cement production plant.

Francesco Risia*, Claudio Poggiania

aDepartment of Engineering, University of Perugia, Via G. Duranti 67, 06125 Perugia, Italy

Abstract

This work presents a study on a gas-solid cyclone separator used in a complex cement production plant. The main objective of the study consists on the performance evaluation and optimization of the cyclone separator in terms of particle separation and heat transfer efficiencies, while keeping pressure losses under control. The thermal interaction is between two gas-solid mixtures, one at 850 °C and the other at 600 °C, respectively. The solid phase consists mostly of calcium carbonate subsequently intended to the so-called baking process for the production of clinker and ultimately cement. A first model has been setup using experimental data as boundary conditions to assess the physical model behavior and the CFD solver parameters. After that, five additional models with different geometries have been analysed to evaluate the influence of the vortex finder (vf) length on the separation efficiency and on the heat exchange performance. Increasing the length of the vf, the results show a global improvement in the separation efficiency of up to 5% if compared to the geometry without the vf. Further, the increasing of the vf length determines a monotonic decrease of temperature at the exit but a monotonic increase of pressure losses. In the second part of this work, using one of the previous models with vf, a study of the influence of the particle diameter on the separation efficiency has been performed. The increaseof particle diameter causes an increase of the separation and thermal exchange performance, decreasing at the same time the pressure drop. The numerical approach for all the cases is based on implicit unsteady simulations using the Eulerian Multiphase model

© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.Org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-reviewunderresponsibilityoftheScientificCommitteeof ATI 2015

Keywords: cyclone; Eulerian multiphase; gas-solid heat exchange; computational fluid dynamics; geometrical optimization.

* Corresponding author. Tel.: +39-075-5853742. E-mail address: francesco.risi@studenti.unipg.it.

1876-6102 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license

(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).

Peer-review under responsibility of the Scientific Committee of ATI 2015

doi: 10.1016/j.egypro.2015.11.834

1. Introduction

The present studyis a step of a longer activity aimed to optimizethe heat exchange betweena flow of gasat high temperature (about 900°C) and the raw materialpowder(consistinglargelyof calcium carbonate), to be submitted to thecooking processfor the productionof"clinker", and then of cement.Much of thisheat exchange takes placein apreheating towerconstituted bycyclones andconnection pipes: the flow ofhot air from theovenmeets, in countercurrent,the raw materialto be preheated. The dried raw meal is preheated and even partially calcined (dry/semi-wet processes) while is held in suspension with the hot gases coming from the rotary kiln. At least in theory, a wider contact surface allows a heat exchange nearly complete. These systemsusually have fromfour tosix stagesofcyclones, which are arranged one over the otherto forma tower with a height varying from 50 to 120m. The stadiumon topcan beconstituted by twoparallelcyclonesfora better separationof the powder.In general, the task of a cyclone is the removal of solid particles from a gas with a consequent beneficial effect on the air pollution control. At this aim, a lot of studies available in literature [1-15], developed by many authors, have been widely studied both numerically and experimentally with the main goal of increasing the separation efficiency. Multiple studies [1-8] demonstrated the decisive influence of both operating parameters and design on the separation efficiency and pressure drop.

The CFD-3D analysis is an efficient and economical approach of understanding the fluid dynamics process in complex plants, providing a precious way to evaluate how it is affected by changes of operating conditions and geometric shapes. At this aim, the CFD approach has been used by many authors [1, 8-15]; the papers deal with issues relative to the flow of gas-solid suspensions predicting solid separation efficiency, at different operating conditions, in good agreement with the experimental evidences. Furthermore, in [13-15] the authors proved as the Reynolds Stress Model is the suitable turbulent model for cyclone with strong swirling flow.

In this work, the authors used the CFD approach to evaluate numerically the thermal exchange, the separation efficiency and the influence of the grain size on the cyclone performance.

The complex plant studied in the present paper is an assembly of cyclones as a part of a process whose industrial goal is the production of the cement. This type of problem can be classified as a multiphase system with heat exchange where the air is the continuous phase, at a temperature of 850 °C and the dispersed phase at 600 °C consisting, mostly, of Calcium Carbonate (density equal to 2063 kg/m3), subsequently intended to the so-called baking process, in order to produce clinker and then cement.

In the first phase, some simulations were carried out with the aim of obtaining results in agreement with the available experimental data; these simulations were executed on the reference case #1, characterized by the vf length equal to zero.

Figure 1: geometry (a,b) and mesh representation (c) of the cyclone system

2. Model

2.1. Cyclone separator

Together with the table 1, fig. 1(b) shows the geometrical dimensions of the cyclone separator model. Fig. 1(c) shows the volumetric model where A and B represent the main and secondary feed respectively; the same figure shows the mesh constituted by about 500000 polyhedral volumetric cells with a base size of 10 cm, a minimum cell size of 2 cm and 2 prism layers at the walls. The transparent visualization enables to see the presence of the vortex finders, the lengthof whichcharacterizesthe sixsimulated models.

Table 1: Geometry of the cyclone

Parameter Symbol Size [mm] Parameter Symbol Size [mm]

Diameter of upper vortex finder D1 3370 Length of upper vortex finder L2 *

Diameter of upper cylindrical part D2 6250 Length of upper conical part L3 5670

Diameter of lower vortex finder D3 2320 Length of lower cylindrical part L4 4583

Diameter of lower cylindrical part D4 4330 Length of lower conical part L5 4119

Diameter of upper spigot D5 780 Length of upper cylindrical part L6 2891

Diameter of lower spigot D6 500 Length of lower outlet tube L7 11700

Length of upper outlet tube L1 8014 Length of lower vortex finder L8 *

2.2. Numerical model

For incompressible, unsteady and non-isothermal flow in cyclone separator, the eulerian-multiphase model has been used. This model treats a dispersed multiphase flow as two (or more) fully interpenetrating quasi-fluid and also considers the interpenetrating effect of each phase by using drag model. The volume fraction of each phase is defined on the basis of the distribution of each phase and the size of computational volume. The difficulty solvingthis model is twofold:first, the equations are difficult from a numerical point of view, since there are many coupled equations with one shared pressure;secondly, to solve the equations, closure models are required for tandFk, which represent respectively the rheology of the phase and the interaction force with the other phases.

A 2-Layer Realizable K-e model has been applied to the gas phase and a Modified Johnson Frictional model was used to evaluate the stresses in granular medium.

The CCM+ 9.6 packagewas used to solve the equations by the finite volume method. The boundary conditions concerning the feed of the cyclone (A and B in fig. 1(c)) are summarized in table 2

Table 2: Boundary conditions

Inlet port Gas mass flow [kg/ s] Solid mass flow rate [kg/ s] Gas/solid temp [°C]

A 31 25.5 850

B 36 23.5 600

3. Results and discussions

Tables 3 summarize the various length of the vf used in 18 different simulation. To analyse the influence of the top and bottom stage, each section was singly analysed. The first 6 simulation was performed varying only the length of upper vf, after that other 6 simulation was performed varying only the bottom vf length, and, at last 6 simulation was performed varying all the vf length.

Table 3: Variation of the vf length of all cyclones

case upper vf length [m] lower vf length [m]

#1 0 0

#2 0.44 0.37

#3 0.87 0.75

#4 1.31 1.12

#5 1.73 1.50

#6 2.60 2.25

The simulation #1 (with vf=0), reproduces exactly the systemcurrently in operation; the experimental values of temperature at the exit, pressure drop and separation efficiency differ, from the simulated one no more than 1.5%.

The greater is the vortex finder length the greater is the number of particles that bumps against its wall. The frictions and collisions are the basis of decrease of particles velocity, then promoting their collection. The slight decrease of temperature at the exit, is due to the simultaneous increase of the contact time of the two feeds caused by a greateraverage particlepath, before their expulsion (Figure 2). It is also obvious the reason of the modest increase of the pressure drop that it is the effect due to the increasing intrusiveness of the vortex finder.

Figure 2: 2D representation of gas temperature concerning the cases #1 and described in Table 3

In the previous figure, it is possible to observe the positive effect of the vortex finder on the separation efficiency mainly due to the barrier effect while, to the other site, there is a negative effect on the pressure drop whose increase is due to the vf intrusiveness.

Figure 3 represent the value of separation efficiency (left) and gas outlet temperature for the 16 cases. Taking into account the simulation #5, the introduction of vf, produces an increment of the separation efficiency of about 1% and a reduction of gas outlet temperature of about 1.7%; respect to the case #1.

The simulations #5A and #5B (Table 4) implement another parametric study developed by varying the particle grain size. Table 6 compares the two simulations with the previous case #5. As well known in literature [1-3, 5, 6, 10, 14], it highlights that, increasing the grain size, the separation efficiency increases while the temperature at the exit and the pressure drop, decreases. Gravity, centrifugal forces and friction play a fundamental role on the decrease of kinetic energy of particles and then on the increasing of the efficiency.

0.942 0.940

>, 0.938 g

.Î 0.936 E

LU 0.934

= 0.932 Î5

g" 0,930 CO

0.928 0.926

—•— 1 ) Upper Cyclones Variation • 2) Lower Cyclones Variation —3) All Cyclones Variation

^ 692 -E

—|— j) Lppertydsm Variation

Figure 3: Separation efficiency (left) and gas outlet temperature (right) trend for the 18 simulation, grouper by geometry type. Table 4: Effect of the particle diameter on the separation efficiency on the temperature at the exit and on the pressure drop

Case Particle diameter [urn]

#5A 30

#5B 120

Separation efficiency [a] 0.722 0.937 0.984

Gas outlet temperature [°C] 722 682 678

Pressure drop [Pa] 785 659 476

Figure 4: Influence of grain size variation on particle volume fraction (left) and gas temperature (right).

4. Conclusions

The present study is a parametric study that considers, as parameters, the vortex finder length and the particle grain size, alternatively. The experimental values of temperature at the exit, pressure drop and separation efficiency differ, from the simulated case #1 (vf length=0), no more than 1.5%. Case #1 reproduces the geometry of the systemcurrently in operation. In all simulated cases, the greater is the vf

length the greater is the solid separation efficiency, while the pressure drop constantly increases of a few Pascals and the exit temperature decreases until a certain value of the vf length and then inverts its trend.

The last part of the work evaluates the effect of the particle grain size on the main performance parameters of the cyclone. To this aim, three cases were simulated with particle diameter equal to 30^, 63 ^ and 120^, corresponding to the cases #5 A, #5 and #5B respectively. 63 ^ is the mean particle diameter value in the operating system. The increase of the particle diameter, results in a better separation efficiency up to 9%, in the case # 5B, with a consequent low variation percent of the exit temperature and a considerable decrease of the pressure drop.It is in progress an activity of simulation,of the same plant, that considers the simultaneous presenceof particles with different diameters according to asuitabledistribution function.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the precious contribute of ColacemS.p.A, - Gubbio (Italy) References

[1] JinW. Lee, Hoe J. Yang, Dong Y. Lee, Effect of the cylinder shape of a long-coned cyclone on the stable flow-field establishment, Powder Technol. 165 (2006) 30-38.

[2] K.S. Lim, H.S. Kim, K.W. Lee, Characteristics of the collection efficiency for a cyclone with different vortex finder shapes, Aerosol Sci. 35 (2004) 743-754.

[3] Fuping Qian, Jiguang Zhang, Mingyao Zhang, Effects of the prolonged vertical tube on the separation performance of a cyclone, J. Hazard. Mater. B136 (2006) 822-829.

[4] Jihui Chen, Lu. Xiaofeng, Hanzhou Liu, et al., Effect of the bottom-contracted and edge-sloped vent-pipe on the cyclone separator performance, Chem. Eng. J. 129 (2007) 85-90.

[5] Bingtao Zhao, Henggen Shen, Yanming Kang, Development of a symmetrical spiral inlet to improve cyclone separator performance, Powder Technol. 145 (2004) 47-50.

[6] K.S. Lim, S.B. Kwon, K.W. Lee, Characteristics of the collection efficiency for a double inlet cyclone with clean air, Aerosol Sci. 34 (2003) 1085-1095.

[7] Anqiao Zheng, Su. Yaxin, Xin Wan, Experimental study of a square-shaped separator with different inlet forms, J. Eng. Thermophys. Energy Power 23 (2008) 293-297.

[8] S. Bernardo, M. Mori, A.P. Peres, et al., 3-D computational fluid dynamics for gas and gas-particle flows in a cyclone with different inlet section angles, Powder Technol. 162 (2006) 190-200.

[9] B. Wang, D.L. Xu, K.W. Chu, et al., Numerical study of gas-solid flow in a cyclone separator, Appl. Math. Model 30 (2006)1326-1342.

[10] Kaya Fuat, Karagozlrfan, Numerical investigation of performance characteristics of a cyclone prolonged with a dipleg, Chem. Eng. J. 151 (2009) 39-45.

[11] K. UdayaBhaskar, Y. Rama Murthy, M. Ravi Raju, et al., CFD simulation and experimental validation studies on hydro cyclone, Miner. Eng. 20 (2007) 60-71[12] R.B. Xiang, K.W. Lee, Numerical study of flow field in cyclones of different height, Chem. Eng. Process. 44 (2005) 877-883.

[13] A.J. Hoekstra, J.J. Derksen, H.E.A. Van Den Akker, An experimental and umerical study of turbulent swirling flow in gas cyclones, Chem. Eng. Sci. 54 (1999) 2055-2056.

[14] K. Pant, C.T. Crowe, P. Irving, On the design of miniature cyclones for the collection of bioaerosols, Powder Technol. 125 issues 2-3 (2002) 260-265.

[15] M. Sommerfeld, C.H. Ho, Numerical calculation of particle transport in turbulent wall bounded flows, Powder Technol. 131 (2003) 1-6.

[16] Lu. Junfu, Jiansheng Zhang, Hai Zhang, et al., Performance evaluation of a 220 t/h CFB boiler with water-cooled square cyclones, Fuel Process. Technol. 88 (2007) 129-135.

[17] Yaxin Su, Anqiao Zheng, Bingtao Zhao, Numerical simulation of effect of inlet configuration on square cyclone separator performance, Powder Technol. 210 (2011) 293-303.

Biography

Francesco Risi Born in Tarquinia (VT) on 11/06/1984. Graduate in Mechanical Engineering in Perugia in 2012; currently enrolled at the second year of PhD school in Industrial Engineering. He focused his research activity in numerical analysis of internal and external flow of machines using CFD/3D analysis.