CC BY
0Placenta xxx (2015) 1-8
¡¡¡kjjjS^ Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/placenta
Current opinion
Animal models of fetal growth restriction: Considerations for translational medicine
A.M. Swanson, A.L. David*
Prenatal Therapy Group, Institute for Women's Health, University College London, 86-96 Chenies Mews, London WC1E 6HX, UK
Tkoi'hoblas i Research
ARTICLE INFO
ABSTRACT
Article history: Accepted 4 March 2015
Keywords:
Fetal growth restriction Animal models Translational medicine
Fetal growth restriction (FGR) is the failure of a fetus to reach its full genetic growth potential. It occurs in up to 8% of pregnancies, and after premature birth is the second leading cause of infant mortality and morbidity. There is no treatment currently available for FGR. Its primary cause, when not attributable to structural or genetic defects of the fetus, is 'placental insufficiency'. This broad definition covers the inability of the fetus to acquire sufficient nutrients and oxygen, and is influenced by a number of factors including altered maternal or fetal blood flow, reduced nutrient transport or changes in the placenta such as increased barrier thickness inhibiting nutrient transfer. For those researchers studying FGR and developing new therapies, choosing an animal model is a crucial consideration. It is vital to clearly frame the question being asked, as this will impact the factor influencing fetal nutrient delivery in the model, and will also affect the applicability of the results to the human condition. This review examines the range of in vivo models of FGR available for those engaged in translational research.
© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
1. Introduction
Fetal growth restriction (FGR) is a failure of a fetus to reach its full genetic growth potential. It occurs in up to 8% of pregnancies, and is the second leading cause of infant mortality and morbidity, following premature birth. Not only are the personal consequences severe, care of these children places a huge financial burden on health care systems, and on social welfare if they survive past infancy. Perhaps more alarmingly, there is no treatment currently available for FGR. When severe and early onset, parents may face the stark choice of delivering a very preterm and possibly non-viable baby, or letting the fetus die in utero. Tables 1-6.
The primary cause of FGR, when not attributable to structural or genetic defects of the fetus, is 'placental insufficiency'. This is a global term covering the failure of the fetus to acquire nutrients and oxygen adequate for its needs, and is influenced by a number of factors including altered maternal or fetal blood flow, reduced nutrient transport or changes in the placenta such as increased barrier thickness inhibiting nutrient transfer. Asymmetrical FGR can result in severe cases, a compensatory process whereby brain
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +44 7852 220375. E-mail address: a.david@ucl.ac.uk (A.L. David).
growth is preserved at the expense of other structures such as the liver, abdomen and long bones, a process termed 'brain sparing'.
When choosing an animal model in which to study FGR and to develop new therapies, it is important to clearly frame the question being asked, as this will have consequences for the factor influencing fetal nutrient delivery in the model, and also for the applicability of the results to the human condition.
2. Why use animal models
We use animal models as the complexity they provide better reproduces the human condition. Some aspects of pregnancy, such as trophoblast development, placentation and placental transport, can be studied in vitro. Human placental villous explants are used to study the materno—fetal interface. The effect of drugs on villous growth and syncytiotrophoblast regeneration can be investigated, or explants from patients with known pathologies can be compared with normal controls for functional studies (reviewed in Ref. [1]). Primary trophoblastic cells isolated from placentas can be cultured short term to study cell function and extrapolate placental remodelling [2,3]. Intricate experimental techniques such as the dual perfusion model of the human placenta [4], where a complete, delivered, human placenta is reperfused in vitro, can be used to look at utero-placental
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.placenta.2015.03.003
0143-4004/© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
A.M. Swanson, A.L. David / Placenta xxx (2015) 1-8
Table 1
Mouse.
Table 3
Guinea pig.
Advantages
Disadvantages
Small size and social nature thus easy to maintain and relatively inexpensive to house Short gestation reduces the time and expense especially to second and third generation studies
Small size means may be problematic to manipulate surgically Imaging of the fetus or placenta can be technically challenging Can be difficult to follow serially postnatally, due to cannibalization and the challenge of marking newborn mice Differences between human and mouse physiology, though generally well characterized and understood Altricial young
Intervention Characteristics Reference
Erk3-'- Fetal growth restriction with 25—40% reduction of visceral organ growth 40% die at birth from acute respiratory failure, similar to respiratory distress syndrome in humans [77]
VEGF knockout Homozygous is embryonic lethal heterozygous results in fetal growth restriction [65]
eNOS-'- Fetal growth restriction with brain sparing, hypoxia and reduced placental system A transport [67]
Placental specific 30% fetal growth restriction [66]
1GF2-'- (P0) with brain sparing
Protein restriction Fetal growth restriction with adiposity [58]
'Crowded uterine Unilateral ovariectomy pre-pregnancy [11]
horn' producing a normal size litter in single horn Differential blood flow results in fetal growth restriction in the middle fetuses
Table 2
Advantages Disadvantages
• Short gestation, • More expensive due
large litters to size increase over mice
• Large enough for complex • Altricial young
surgical intervention
• Useful for intergeneration
studies especially cognitive
1ntervention Characteristics Reference
Uterine artery ligation
Uterine artery
occlusion (60 min)
Dexamethasone administration
l-name
administration
Hypoxia
Nutrient restriction
Protein restriction
40% fetal growth restriction with brain sparing high level fetal loss and resorption Fetal growth restriction with brain sparing fetal mortality 14% 15% fetal growth restriction chronic hypertension in adult offspring
Fetal growth restriction [80,81]
up to 20%, increased stillbirth dependent on dose regimen
Both chronic and intermittent [82—84]
hypoxia in second half of
pregnancy effective
4—37% fetal growth restriction,
varied level of exposure
Fetal growth restriction up to [51,55,85]
35% both acute fasting and chronic
restriction effective significant
changes to the IGF axis in offspring
15% fetal growth restriction [59]
Advantages Disadvantages
• Haemomonochorial • Longer gestation, larger animal,
placenta smaller litters thus more expensive
• Extensive trophoblast • Less common laboratory animal
invasion so specific reagents/equipment
• Longer gestation, better more expensive
for therapeutic evaluation
• Precocial young thus brain
development more like
human than other rodents
1ntervention Characteristics Reference
Uterine artery 40—60% fetal growth restriction [42,86,87]
ligation in a proportion of fetuses High rate of fetal death Reduced oxygen and nutrient delivery to fetus
Radial artery 30% fetal growth restriction [46]
diathermy with brain sparing reduction in brain growth, both volume and neuronal number
Maternal nutrient Both acute fasting and chronic [52,54]
restriction restriction effective 10—39% fetal growth restriction with brain sparing altered trophoblast density, placental barrier thickness
haemodynamics and drug transfer but only short term (up to 9 h) before the integrity of the placental barrier is compromised. Currently, this ex vivo technique is the only model available to study organised human placental tissue. Setting up the perfusion experiments is complicated by a high rate of failures due to tissue damage compromising the integrity of the placental barrier. The technique has been used to study placental toxicology and the transfer of drugs and endogenous (eg amino acids and hormones) and exogenous (eg viruses and therapeutics) substrates [5,6]. Dual placental perfusion has also been used in preeclampsia to examine the vasodilatory effects of VEGF [7], a
Table 4
Other small mammals.
Rabbit advantages Dog advantages
• Predictable • More invasive trophoblast
reproductive cycle than other domestic animals
• Familiar to regulators for
reproductive toxicology
• Fetal growth chronologically
comparable to human
Intervention Characteristics Reference
Rabbit
natural model
Rabbit thermal
placental injury Rabbit high
cholesterol diet Rabbit selective
uterine artery ligature
Canine acute nutrient restriction
Based on fetal position
in the uterine horn
15% fetal growth restriction
Depressed expression
of 1GF-1 mRNA and lower
serum and amniotic fluid
levels of 1GF-1 protein
30% fetal growth restriction [88]
with brain sparing
15% fetal growth restriction
28% fetal growth restriction [50]
increased fetal mortality
compared to undernutrition
Doppler parameters more closely
reproduce human FGR
10% fetal growth restriction [90]
alterations in fasting glucose
and fat metabolism
A.M. Swanson, AL. David / Placenta xxx (20Í5) Í—8
Table 5
Other large mammals.
Sheep advantages
Sheep disadvantages
Serial sampling from both sides of the placental barrier in unanaesthetised and unstressed animal possible Sheep conceptus relevant to human fetal physiology Consistent gestation with predominantly singleton pregnancies Good tolerance for in utero manipulation
Placentation is not closely
similar to human
Large animal facility needed
Intervention
Characteristics
Reference
Pig natural runt
carunculectomy
Sheep nutrient restricted adult
Sheep overfed adolescent
hyperthermia
Sheep maternal hypoxia
Goat nutrient
or protein restriction
Horse crossbreed
Asymmetrical fetal growth restriction, [15,91]
improved cerebral oxygen utilisation
30% fetal growth restriction reduction [48,92]
in glucose consumption by placenta
and oxygen supply to the fetus,
increase in placental efficiency
Mild FGR, 17% reduced uterine [50]
blood flow, reduced placental
capillary density
FGR, brain sparing, reduced [56]
uterine blood flow (36%) and umbilical artery blood flow
46-74% fetal growth restriction with [60]
brain sparing reduced uterine and
umbilical artery blood flow
25% fetal growth restriction [93]
systolic and diastolic fetal cardiac
dysfunction
5-10% fetal growth restriction altered [94] fetal thymus, small intestine, kidney and liver weights relative to body weight IVF experiments in Shetland ponies [95]
and thoroughbred racehorses, fetus is constrained by the size of the surrogate mother
potent angiogenic factor which has also been implicated as playing a role in altered placental angiogenesis in FGR [8,9]. Nevertheless, despite the advances made using in vitro models of some aspects of pregnancy, the condition of FGR as a whole is more accurately represented in vivo. Still other features of pregnancy, such as the development of the uteroplacental circulation, fetal growth velocity and fetal development have no in vitro counterpart. When new therapies become available, although they are first tested extensively in vitro, they must present a clean reproductive toxicology panel in vivo [10] before they are deemed fit for use in humans, hence animal experiments are necessary.
Table б
Non-human primates.
Advantages
Disadvantages
Genetically, closest model to human Pregnancy characterised by trophoblast invasion of the spiral arteries
High cost and dedicated facility needed Ethical considerations Study numbers generally small Interventions cause high rates of fetal loss
Intervention Characteristics Reference
Baboon nutrient 10% fetal growth restriction, changes [96]
restriction to fetal brain, liver, kidney, placenta
Rhesus macaque 6-14% fetal growth restriction [97,98]
ligation of placental with asymmetrical growth, dependent
bridging vessels on time of insult, 40% reduction
in functional placenta
3. Considerations when studying animal pregnancies
There are a number of species-specific factors to be considered when using animals to model human pregnancy. The number of offspring per pregnancy, placentation, gestation length, parturition and fetal versus neonatal development will all affect the choice of model.
3.1. Fetal number
A large litter size has the advantage of acquiring good quality data from a minimal number of pregnancies, reducing the overall number of animals required. Differences between the sexes can also be studied more easily. Additionally, animals with large litters such as rabbits and pigs have a 'natural' model for FGR in the runt of the litter. These animals can also be 'forced' into creating runts where a normal size litter is carried in a single uterine horn following a unilateral ovariectomy [11,12]. For rabbits, pups in the middle of the uterine horn are consistently smaller than their littermates, as they are further away from the blood supply arriving via ovarian or cervical ends of the uterine artery. In a natural rabbit model of FGR, when compared to kits in the 'favoured' positions nearer the arterial source, runts are consistently smaller. At term, the weight ratio of favoured to FGR fetus is 0.85 [13,14]. They also have depressed liver, kidney, and intestinal expression of insulin growth factor 1(IGF-1) mRNA as well as lower serum and amniotic fluid levels of IGF-1 protein, a key component in modulating fetal growth that is reduced in the cord blood at term of human babies with FGR [14]. Piglet runts spontaneously display asymmetric growth restriction [15]. For direct fetal treatment however, a large number of fetuses can make intervention technically difficult. Fetal measurements can also be challenging and time-consuming, and interventions may have a prolonged anaesthetic time. There are also statistical considerations to be taken into account with litters. Pup birth weight varies with position, watershed area, sex, number, gestational age at delivery and intervention. Importantly, when considering interventions given to mothers, the mother is the unit of measurement and pups are nested within mothers. Sample size calculations and analysis of the primary and secondary outcomes in a study must account for all these factors to be able to see the true effect of an intervention.
3.2. Length of gestation
Small animals, such as rodents and rabbits, tend to have short gestation lengths. Much of the development that would take place during fetal life in the human occurs in the neonatal period in these animals. This makes them less relevant as models for the consequences of FGR in the neonate, especially with regard to neurological impact. However, their shorter lifespan is an advantage for the study of trans-generational effects, significantly reducing the time needed to gather data. Among rodents the guinea pig is an exception, having a comparatively long gestation, but there is a lack of genetic models of disease in this species. A long gestation length can also confer considerable advantages. There is an increased time in which to evaluate the effect of a therapy or intervention on multiple parameters such as fetal development, fetal growth, and miscarriage rates. These advantages must be weighed against the cost of maintaining animals over the longer period, finally coming down to a justification of the cost of the model versus the quality and type of data that it will provide.
3.3. Placental shape
Placentation is a complex process, and as the majority of FGR arises from placental insufficiency there are several aspects of
A.M. Swanson, AL David / Placenta xxx (2015) 1—8
placentation which need to be considered. The human placenta is discoidal in shape, as it is in higher primates and rodents, with a single disc-like zone of close maternofetal contact. This provides the highest concentration of maternofetal interdigitation, an intricate system of folds which increases the area of contact between mother and fetus. Lower primates and pigs have a diffuse placenta, where the interdigitation is distributed over the entire maternofetal exchange area. Ruminants, including sheep, have a cotyledonary placenta, in which many spot-like regions of intense maternofetal interdigitations exist.
3.4. Interdigitation
Interdigitation can be further sub-divided into five types [16]. Folded interdigitations are the most simple, with ridge-like folds of the chorion that fit into corresponding grooves of the uterine mucosa, and are found only in animals which have a diffuse placenta, such as pigs. Lamellar interdigitation is more complex, with ridges branching into parallel chorionic lamellae interspersed with branched endometrial folds, and is seen in some types of carnivore. The trabecular type has interdigitations from which leaflike and finger-like villi branch, and has been described in some monkeys. Sheep, humans and other higher primates have villous interdigitation, where the chorion has a tree-like branching pattern, and villi either fit into endometrial crypts or are directly bathed in maternal blood. The final and most common type is labyrinthine, found in rodents, where a trophoblastic mass is permeated by a network of channels filled with maternal blood or fetal capillaries.
3.5. Interface
The type of maternal—fetal interface [16] present is important for passive transfer of oxygen across the placenta. Across species there appears to be a relationship between the number of cell layers in the placental exchange barrier and permeability [17]. In the synepitheliochorial placenta for example, such as found in ruminants, there are six layers of tissue between maternal and fetal blood [18]. This compares to one syncytiotrophoblast layer in the late gestation haemomonochorial human placenta. Perfusion experiments and calculations suggest that the permeability of the sheep placenta is at least one order of magnitude less than that of the human [19]. In an endotheliochorial placenta, seen primarily in carnivores, invading trophoblasts face the maternal endothelium and only five tissue layers separate the maternal and fetal circulation. In a haemochorial placenta, the trophoblasts also erode the maternal vessels and so maternal blood bathes the syncytio-trophoblast and there are just three tissue layers between maternal and fetal blood. Depending on the number of trophoblastic epithelial layers a more detailed subdivision has been proposed, which in humans depends on the gestational age: haemotrichorial (rat and mouse), haemodichorial (rabbit and human in the first trimester), and haemomonochorial (great apes, guinea pig and human at term). This has implications for drug testing in animals. For example, if placental transfer of a drug intended for early pregnancy were being investigated, a rabbit model may be preferred. If the drug was to be administered only in late pregnancy, a guinea pig model may be more appropriate.
3.6. Placental transport
A maternal—fetal counter current arrangement is deemed the most efficient anatomical arrangement of blood vessels, yet placentas with counter current flows, such as the guinea pig [20], rat and rabbit are not more efficient than other types, such as
crosscurrent in the sheep, where fetus produced per gram placenta (a measure of placental efficiency) is equivalent [21]. Facilitated and active transports are important to overall placental efficiency, as is the total surface are available for diffusion. Nutrients such as glucose and lactate are transferred across the placenta by facilitated transport via transporter proteins. There are several isoforms of the glucose transporter, which are differentially distributed in the human placenta, and vary from distribution in other animals (reviewed in Ref. [22]). Active transport of essential amino acids and ions such as sodium and potassium is mediated by a range of specific transporters, and the activity of these transporters may also differ between species [23]. Alterations in the activity of certain nutrient transporters have been seen in human FGR [24,25] and some animal models of FGR [23,25—27]. Transport of proteins across the placenta is largely restricted to proteins of specific use to the fetus, such as immunoglobins, although this is confined to hemochorial placentas. Active transport of immunoglobulins occurs via the placenta in humans, and via the yolk sac in rodents and rabbits [28]. In contrast to the human placenta, epithelio- and endotheliochorial placentas are impermeable to proteins, and immunoglobins are transferred in the colostrum after birth [16]. Examination of the maternal and/or fetal immune response to fetal interventions in these animal models therefore needs to consider this aspect when trying to translate into the clinical situation.
3.7. Trophoblast invasion
The extent to which fetal trophoblast invade the maternal tissue and remodel the spiral arteries is also an important consideration. No other organism has such extensive invasion as humans, and both the extent and depth of trophoblast invasion is suboptimal in FGR [29]. Trophoblast invasion is shallow in most rodents, with rats having more extensive invasion than mice, where uterine artery transformation is more dependent on maternal factors such as natural killer cells, than on trophoblast invasion [30,31]. In humans, trophoblast invasion is crucial to adequate supply of blood to the placenta, so the mouse would not be a suitable model for investigation into the causes of inadequate spiral artery remodelling, nor any interventions aimed at promoting trophoblast invasion. In contrast, the guinea pig has extensive trophoblast invasion, which spreads deep into the walls of the uterine arteries [32,33]. The sheep, as with other ruminants, has no trophoblast invasion, and while the maternal vessels in the rabbit are lined with multinu-cleated cells it has not been established that these are trophoblastic [30]. The canine placenta is more invasive than other domestic animal models, however it more closely resembles a human pre-eclamptic transformation than a normal pregnancy [34]. As the nearest genetic relative to the human, it is unsurprising that in nonhuman primates the remodelling of the spiral arteries following trophoblast invasion most closely resembles the human condition [35,36]. Even so, there remain some differences between the species, such as a relative lack of interstitial trophoblast cells in nonhuman primates.
4. Creating animal models of fetal growth restriction
Animal models of FGR fall into three broad categories when divided by method of intervention creating the model: fetal intervention, maternal intervention, and genetic models. For each commonly used species we list a selection of FGR models in Tables 1 —6. The primary model using fetal intervention is the hypoxic chick [37—39]. The principal advantage of this model is the ability to investigate the effects of hypoxia in the fetus in isolation, without affecting the mother. In many growth restricted human pregnancies caused by placental insufficiency, there is no alteration
A.M. Swanson, AL David / Placenta xxx (2015) 1—8 5
in the health status of the mother. Alternative fetal interventions include infection with certain viruses and dosing with radioactive iodine, however these are not useful for translational medicine.
There are a range of maternal interventions capable of creating FGR in an animal model. The oldest interventions directly alter the uterine circulation, reducing maternal nutrient and oxygen transport to the placenta. Uterine artery ligation has been shown to cause FGR in rats, guinea pigs, and sheep [40—44]. Similarly, radial artery diathermy in guinea pigs and uterine artery embolization in sheep also result in FGR [45—47]. Although the result is FGR, the lack of an intact uteroplacental circulation in these models renders them less useful for testing maternal therapies that target uterine blood flow or the placental barrier directly. A related intervention is sheep carunclectomy, in which the maternal portion of the pla-centomes — the multiple contact points between maternal and fetal blood circulations in the placenta — are surgically removed from the uterus prior to pregnancy. This creates FGR in about half of pregnancies [48], illustrating the relative redundancy of the sheep placenta.
Global interventions in the mother are also able to cause FGR in pregnancy. In humans, a major reduction in calorie intake is needed to influence fetal weight, such as occurred in the World War II Dutch famine, and the effect is dependent on the trimester of pregnancy in which it occurs [49]. As is to be expected, maternal nutrient restriction results in smaller fetuses with asymmetrical growth in several models, including rat, guinea pig, rabbit, and sheep [50—55]. Interestingly, overfeeding in an adolescent pregnant ewe also causes FGR, as growth of the mother is maintained at the expense of fetal development [56]. Alternatively, restriction of specific nutrients such as in low protein or low sodium diets, rather than overall calorie reduction, can also impact the growth of the fetus in several models [57—59]. Environmental factors are also capable of influencing pregnancy outcome. Following observations of low birthweight lambs from sheep raised in hot conditions, a heat stress model of FGR was developed [60]. Fetuses showed evidence of brain sparing, and umbilical and uterine blood flow was reduced [60,61]. The hyperthermic conditions were able to be imposed at various time points, and highlighted that the timing of intervention used to create the FGR model can have a large impact on the resulting disease phenotype. Finally, pregnancy at high altitude or a period spent in a hypoxic chamber, limiting the oxygen supply to the mother and thereby to the placenta and fetus, can cause FGR, though this varies by species and again is dependent on the gestational timing of the insult. Using animals that are native or naive to high altitude mimics the effects seen in human pregnancy, in which compensatory mechanisms such as altered enzymatic antioxidant activity may contribute to native protection from some of the consequences of a reduced oxygen tension [62].
Genetic models of FGR have generally been created in the mouse (recently reviewed in Ref. [63]), aided by the wealth of molecular information available in that species and ready access to embryonic stem cells. Early knockout models proved to be overly severe, and resulted in embryonic lethal phenotypes. Global disruption of Tissue Factor, also known as platelet tissue factor, factor III, thrombokinase, or CD142, resulted in fatal wasting of mouse offspring after embryonic day 9.5 [64]. Unconditional knockout of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), a signal protein which is essential for angiogenesis during development, also produces an embryonic lethal phenotype [65]. More refined models are now available, with conditional or tissue-restricted knockout of specific genes. In the placental specific insulin-like growth factor 2 (IGF2) knockout mouse model, a transcript of the gene which is expressed only in the placental labyrinthine trophoblast cells is deleted [66]. This results in impaired placental growth from embryonic day 12, and growth restriction in 96% of fetuses by embryonic day 16. Birth
weight is approximately 69% of wild type, although the pups did exhibit postnatal catch up growth. Impaired placental growth is seen earlier in gestation than reduced fetal growth, possibly as a result of increased placental System A activity that may contribute to maintaining fetal growth. Closer to term, the knockout placentas remain smaller, the System A activity is nearer to normal and there is decreased passive permeability as well, all of which likely contribute to the FGR phenotype [66]. A global knockout of the endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) gene, an enzyme which converts arginine to nitric oxide (NO) inducing vasodilation, results in impaired uterine artery function and diminished placental System A amino acid transporter activity [67]. This model shows asymmetric growth and a possible reduction in extraction of oxygen by the fetus [67]. In humans, the level of system A activity is correlated with severity of FGR [24].
For all animal models, using a standardized method to describe and express fetal growth is important. An examples of such a method includes constructing fetal growth curves [68], which allows comparison of animal data with human FGR data, and to quantify how much of an improvement in fetal growth an intervention might achieve in the clinic.
5. Translational medicine considerations
The practicalities of testing out drugs and therapies in animal models of FGR present numerous challenges, both applied and regulatory [69]. Since many models require an initial surgical intervention, a further surgical intervention may be deemed too stressful for the animal and may not be allowable under animal experiment regulations governing specific countries, or may render insufficient numbers of pups for evaluation. The International Conference on Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH) guidelines govern reproductive toxicity studies in women and men [10], specifying that any programme should allow exposure of the novel chemical to all stages of development throughout one complete life cycle: for example, from conception in one generation through to conception in the following generation. Where more than one investigation is used there must be an overlap between studies so that no gaps are left between key stages. This is especially relevant if a drug affects fertility, when there may not be adequate numbers of pregnant animals or fetuses to properly assess developmental toxicity in utero. In practice, a number of overlapping studies are conducted to cover fertility and early embryonic development, pre-and postnatal development including lactation and weaning, and embryo—fetal development [70]. All studies need to be conducted under Good Laboratory Practice (GLP) conditions, which are extremely costly. Fertility and pre— and postnatal development studies need only be conducted in one mammalian species, which is commonly the rat. For embryofetal development two mammalian species should usually be tested, one should be a rodent, often the rat for pragmatic reasons, and the other a non—rodent, usually the rabbit where there is a large body of historical data for comparison. Alternative species may be considered if there are good reasons such as specifics relating to drug metabolism, although for some species, there may not be much historical data, making interpretation of results challenging (J Baldwin, personal communication).
A translational medicine study is in essence a clinical trial but performed in animals with parallel considerations. Generating the best control group may require collection of local contemporaneous data in the same species without the intervention that created FGR, since relying on historical data may introduce bias. The type of control group is important, whether they be untreated, have a sham intervention or use a control treatment administration. The
A.M. Swanson, A.L. David / Placenta xxx (2015) î-8
advantage of an animal study is that controls can be selected for their appropriateness rather than what is permissible in a patient. Clinical trials are run according to set principles (eg UK Clinical Trials Regulations 2004, EU Clinical Trials Directive 2001), and animal studies should follow similar principles to provide the most robust data. Interventions should be adequately described, study groups should be randomly allocated and blinded where possible, sufficiently powered, with pre-specified clinically important endpoints and results reported together with important adverse events. One example, the ARRIVE (Animal Research: Reporting of In Vivo Experiments) guidelines [71], were developed as part of an initiative by the UK National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement & Reduction of Animals in Research (NC3Rs). The guidelines are intended to improve the design, analysis and reporting of research using animals by maximising the information that is published and minimising unnecessary studies, and have been adopted by many scientific journals.
Additionally relevant to FGR, consideration needs to be given to methods of monitoring fetal loss and growth. Serial measurement in one animal may yield more information than multiple post mortem sampling in a number of different animals. In particular measurement of uterine blood flow is feasible in large animals using ultrasound or implanted flow probes and may yield valuable longitudinal data after intervention [72—74]. Ultrasound allows non-invasive longitudinal monitoring, although it does require skilled technicians, who should be blinded to the intervention where possible [75]. Care should be taken when assessing whether pups are resorbed or not, especially with regard to whether this is due to the intervention/therapy or the creation of FGR.
If animals are going to deliver their offspring there are further considerations. FGR animals often have a higher rate of pregnancy complications, leading to higher fetal and perinatal loss rate. The offspring in some models are very fragile at birth and may be preferentially cannibalised by rodents, or need sustained intervention in order to thrive, some even occasioning an animal "neonatal intensive care unit". Measuring interventions of this nature accurately is challenging. There may be an effect of the creation of FGR on the ability of mother to feed offspring. Among other examples, some FGR ewes have very poor lactation initially and neonatal lambs may need supplemental colostrum [76]. When complications occur, they should be fully investigated, with a detailed post-mortem examination, blood analysis, histology and microbiological analysis where feasible. Evaluation of important long term outcomes such as cardiovascular disease, hypertension, insulin sensitivity and even the F1 generation will need sufficient initial animal numbers to account for these losses. Finally, and by no means to be considered last, are the statistical analysis to evaluate the results which must include consideration of confounding variables (mother weight, litter number, pup sex, pup position etc).
6. Conclusion
Developing new therapies for fetal growth restriction ultimately requires the use of animal models in which to test efficacy and safety. The choice of which animal to use will need to take into consideration the characteristics of pregnancy in the particular animal, and whether to use naturally occurring FGR or FGR created by maternal or fetal intervention, or genetic manipulation. It is important to clearly frame the question being asked, as this will have consequences for the factor influencing fetal nutrient delivery in the model, and also for the applicability of the results to the human condition. Use of guidelines, such as ARRIVE, will improve the quality of the study and minimise unnecessary follow-up studies.
Conflict of interest
We wish to confirm that there are no known conflicts of interest associated with this publication and there has been no significant financial support for this work that could have influenced its outcome.
Acknowledgements
ALD is funded by a HEFCE/Department of Health Clinical Senior Lectureship. AMS is funded by Action Medical Research (GN1738) and the Rosetrees Trust (SP4409). This work was undertaken at UCLH/UCL who received a proportion of funding from the Department of Health NIHR Biomedical Research Centre's funding scheme.
References
[1] Orendi K, Kivity V, Sammar M, Grimpel Y, Gonen R, Meiri H, et al. Placental and trophoblastic in vitro models to study preventive and therapeutic agents for preeclampsia. Placenta 2011;32(Suppl.):S49—54.
[2] Hills FA, Elder MG, Chard T, Sullivan MH. Regulation of human villous trophoblast by insulin-like growth factors and insulin-like growth factor-binding protein-1. J Endocrinol 2004;183(3):487—96.
[3] Pijnenborg R, Luyten C, Vercruysse L, Keith Jr JC, Van Assche FA. Cytotoxic effects of tumour necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha and interferon-gamma on cultured human trophoblast are modulated by fibronectin. Mol Hum Reprod 2000;6(7):635—41.
[4] Schneider H, Panigel M, Dancis J. Transfer across the perfused human placenta of antipyrine, sodium and leucine. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1972;114(6):822—8.
[5] Hutson JR, Garcia-Bournissen F, Davis A, Koren G. The human placental perfusion model: a systematic review and development of a model to predict in vivo transfer of therapeutic drugs. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2011;90(1):67—76.
[6] Myllynen P, Vahakangas K. Placental transfer and metabolism: an overview of the experimental models utilizing human placental tissue. Toxicol Vitro Int J Publ Assoc BIBRA 2013;27(1):507—12.
[7] Brownbill P, Mills TA, Soydemir DF, Sibley CP. Vasoactivity to and endogenous release of vascular endothelial growth factor in the in vitro perfused human placental lobule from pregnancies complicated by preecla6mpsia. Placenta 2008;29(11):950—5.
[8] Barut F, Barut A, Gun BD, Kandemir NO, Harma MI, Harma M, et al. Intra-uterine growth restriction and placental angiogenesis. Diagn Pathol 2010;5: 24.
[9] Mayhew TM, Charnock-Jones DS, Kaufmann P. Aspects of human fetoplacental vasculogenesis and angiogenesis. III. Changes in complicated pregnancies. Placenta 2004;25(2—3):127—39.
[10] International Conference on Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use. ICH harmonised tripartite guideline S8: immunotoxicity studies for human pharmaceuticals. ICH. 2005. Retrieved from: http://www.ich.org/products/guidelines/safety/article/safety-guidelines.html.
[11] Coe BL, Kirkpatrick JR, Taylor JA, vom Saal FS. A new 'crowded uterine horn' mouse model for examining the relationship between foetal growth and adult obesity. Basic Clin Pharmacol Toxicol 2008;102(2):162—7.
[12] Christenson RK, Leymaster KA, Young LD. Justification of unilateral hysterectomy-ovariectomy as a model to evaluate uterine capacity in swine. J Anim Sci 1987;65(3):738—44.
[13] Flake AW, Villa RL, Adzick NS, Harrison MR. Transamniotic fetal feeding. II. A model of intrauterine growth retardation using the relationship of "natural runting" to uterine position. J Pediatr Surg 1987;22(9):816—9.
[14] Thakur A, Sase M, Lee JJ, Thakur V, Buchmiller TL. Ontogeny of insulin-like growth factor 1 in a rabbit model of growth retardation. J Surg Res 2000;91(2):135—40.
[15] Bauer R, Walter B, Hoppe A, Gaser E, Lampe V, Kauf E, et al. Body weight distribution and organ size in newborn swine (sus scrofa domestica) — a study describing an animal model for asymmetrical intrauterine growth retardation. Exp Toxicol Pathol Off J Gesellschaft fur Toxikologische Pathologie 1998;50(1):59—65.
[16] Wooding P, Burton G. Comparative placentation: structures, functions and evolution. Berlin Heidelberg: Springer; 2008.
[17] Sibley CP. Understanding placental nutrient transfer—why bother? new bio-markers of fetal growth. J Physiol 2009;587(Pt 14):3431—40.
[18] Wooding FB. Current topic: the synepitheliochorial placenta of ruminants: binucleate cell fusions and hormone production. Placenta 1992;13(2): 101—13.
[19] Boyd RD, Haworth C, Stacey TE, Ward HT. Permeability of the sheep placenta to unmetabolized polar non-electrolytes. J Physiol 1976;256(3):617—34.
[20] Bailey DJ. Proceedings: counter-current flow of maternal and foetal bloodstreams in guinea-pig placenta. J Physiol 1974;242(2):104P—5P.
[21] Benirschke K, Burton G, Baergen RN. Placental types. New York: Springer; 2012. p. 30—41.
A.M. Swanson, A.L. Dav
[22] Illsley NP. Glucose transporters in the human placenta. Placenta 2000;21(1): 14-22.
[23] Kusinski LC, Jones CJ, Baker PN, Sibley CP, Glazier JD. Isolation of plasma membrane vesicles from mouse placenta at term and measurement of system A and system beta amino acid transporter activity. Placenta 2010;31(1):53-9.
[24] Glazier JD, Cetin I, Perugino G, Ronzoni S, Grey AM, Mahendran D, et al. Association between the activity of the system A amino acid transporter in the microvillous plasma membrane of the human placenta and severity of fetal compromise in intrauterine growth restriction. Pediatr Res 1997;42(4): 514-9.
[25] Jansson N, Pettersson J, Haafiz A, Ericsson A, Palmberg I, Tranberg M, et al. Down-regulation of placental transport of amino acids precedes the development of intrauterine growth restriction in rats fed a low protein diet. J Physiol 2006;576(Pt 3):935-46.
[26] Dilworth MR, Kusinski LC, Cowley E, Ward BS, Husain SM, Constancia M, et al. Placental-specific Igf2 knockout mice exhibit hypocalcemia and adaptive changes in placental calcium transport. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2010;107(8): 3894-9.
[27] Ross JC, Fennessey PV, Wilkening RB, Battaglia FC, Meschia G. Placental transport and fetal utilization of leucine in a model of fetal growth retardation. Am J Physiol 1996;270(3 Pt 1):E491-503.
[28] DeSesso Jm, Williams AL, Ahuja A, Bowman CJ, Hurtt ME. The placenta, transfer of immunoglobulins, and safety assessment of biopharmaceuticals in pregnancy. Crit Rev Toxicol 2012;42(3):185-210.
[29] Khong TY, De Wolf F, Robertson WB, Brosens I. Inadequate maternal vascular response to placentation in pregnancies complicated by pre-eclampsia and by small-for-gestational age infants. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1986;93(10):1049-59.
[30] Carter AM. Animal models of human placentation-a review. Placenta 2007;28(Suppl A):S41-7.
[31] Greenwood JD, Minhas K, di Santo JP, Makita M, Kiso Y, Croy BA. Ultrastructural studies of implantation sites from mice deficient in uterine natural killer cells. Placenta 2000;21(7):693-702.
[32] Clausen HV, Larsen LG, Carter AM. Vascular reactivity of the preplacental vasculature in guinea pigs. Placenta 2003;24(6):686-97.
[33] Nanaev A, Chwalisz K, Frank HG, Kohnen G, Hegele-Hartung C, Kaufmann P. Physiological dilation of uteroplacental arteries in the guinea pig depends on nitric oxide synthase activity of extravillous trophoblast. Cell Tissue Res 1995;282(3):407-21.
[34] Kutzler M, Sahlfeld L, Fellows E. Who let the dogs in: a canine trophoblast invasion model for pre-eclampsia. Reprod Domest Anim Zuchthygiene 2012;47(Suppl. 6):186-9.
[35] Blankenship TN, Enders AC. Modification of uterine vasculature during pregnancy in macaques. Microsc Res Tech 2003;60(4):390-401.
[36] Enders AC, Blankenship TN. Modification of endometrial arteries during invasion by cytotrophoblast cells in the pregnant macaque. Acta anat 1997;159(4):169-93.
[37] Dixon JC, Cady EB, Priest AN, Thornton JS, Peebles DM. Growth restriction and the cerebral metabolic response to acute hypoxia of chick embryos in-ovo: a proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy study. Brain Res Dev brain Res 2005;160(2):203-10.
[38] Miller SL, Green LR, Peebles DM, Hanson MA, Blanco CE. Effects of chronic hypoxia and protein malnutrition on growth in the developing chick. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2002;186(2):261-7.
[39] Mulder AL, van Golde JC, Prinzen FW, Blanco CE. Cardiac output distribution in response to hypoxia in the chick embryo in the second half of the incubation time. J Physiol 1998;508(Pt. 1):281-7.
[40] Carter AM. Current topic: restriction of placental and fetal growth in the guinea-pig. Placenta 1993;14(2):125-35.
[41] Emmanouilides GC, Townsend DE, Bauer RA. Effects of single umbilical artery ligation in the lamb fetus. Pediatrics 1968;42(6):919-27.
[42] Lafeber HN, Rolph TP, Jones CT. Studies on the growth of the fetal guinea pig. The effects of ligation of the uterine artery on organ growth and development. J Dev Physiol 1984;6(6):441-59.
[43] Supramaniam VG, Jenkin G, Loose J, Wallace EM, Miller SL. Chronic fetal hypoxia increases activin A concentrations in the late-pregnant sheep. BJOG Int J Obstet Gynaecol 2006;113(1):102-9.
[44] Wigglesworth JS. Fetal growth retardation. Animal model: uterine vessel ligation in the pregnant rat. Am J Pathol 1974;77(2):347-50.
[45] Ochi H, Matsubara K, Kusanagi Y, Taniguchi H, Ito M. Significance of a diastolic notch in the uterine artery flow velocity waveform induced by uterine em-bolisation in the pregnant ewe. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1998;105(10):1118-21.
[46] Palliser HK, Yates DM, Hirst JJ. Progesterone receptor isoform expression in response to in utero growth restriction in the fetal guinea pig brain. Neuro-endocrinology 2012;96(1):60-7.
[47] Turner AJ, Trudinger BJ. A modification of the uterine artery restriction technique in the guinea pig fetus produces asymmetrical ultrasound growth. Placenta 2009;30(3):236-40.
[48] Owens JA, Falconer J, Robinson JS. Effect of restriction of placental growth on umbilical and uterine blood flows. Am J Physiol 1986;250(3 Pt 2):R427-34.
[49] Lumey LH, Stein AD. Offspring birth weights after maternal intrauterine un-dernutrition: a comparison within sibships. Am J Epidemiol 1997;146(10): 810-9.
[50] Eixarch E, Hernandez-Andrade E, Crispi F, Illa M, Torre I, Figueras F, et al. Impact on fetal mortality and cardiovascular Doppler of selective ligature of
Placenta xxx (2015) 1-8 7
uteroplacental vessels compared with undernutrition in a rabbit model of intrauterine growth restriction. Placenta 2011;32(4):304-9.
[51] Girard JR, Ferre P, Gilbert M, Kervran A, Assan R, Marliss EB. Fetal metabolic response to maternal fasting in the rat. Am J Physiol 1977;232(5):E456-63.
[52] Lingas R, Dean F, Matthews SG. Maternal nutrient restriction (48 h) modifies brain corticosteroid receptor expression and endocrine function in the fetal guinea pig. Brain Res 1999;846(2):236-42.
[53] Newnham JP, Kelly RW, Patterson L, James I. The influence of maternal un-dernutrition in ovine twin pregnancy on fetal growth and Doppler flow-velocity waveforms. J Dev Physiol 1991;16(5):277-82.
[54] Roberts CT, Sohlstrom A, Kind KL, Earl RA, Khong TY, Robinson JS, et al. Maternal food restriction reduces the exchange surface area and increases the barrier thickness of the placenta in the guinea-pig. Placenta 2001;22(2-3): 177-85.
[55] Woodall SM, Breier BH, Johnston BM, Bassett NS, Barnard R, Gluckman PD. Administration ofgrowth hormone or IGF-I to pregnant rats on a reduced diet throughout pregnancy does not prevent fetal intrauterine growth retardation and elevated blood pressure in adult offspring. J Endocrinol 1999;163(1): 69-77.
[56] Wallace JM, Aitken RP, Cheyne MA. Nutrient partitioning and fetal growth in rapidly growing adolescent ewes. J Reprod Fertil 1996;107(2):183-90.
[57] Battista MC, Oligny LL, St-Louis J, Brochu M. Intrauterine growth restriction in rats is associated with hypertension and renal dysfunction in adulthood. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metabol 2002;283(1):E124-31.
[58] Bhasin KK, van Nas A, Martin LJ, Davis RC, Devaskar SU, Lusis AJ. Maternal low-protein diet or hypercholesterolemia reduces circulating essential amino acids and leads to intrauterine growth restriction. Diabetes 2009;58(3): 559-66.
[59] Resnick O, Morgane PJ, Hasson R, Miller M. Overt and hidden forms of chronic malnutrition in the rat and their relevance to man. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 1982;6(1):55-75.
[60] Galan hL, Hussey MJ, Barbera A, Ferrazzi E, Chung M, Hobbins JC, et al. Relationship of fetal growth to duration of heat stress in an ovine model of placental insufficiency. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1999;180(5):1278-82.
[61] Galan HL, Anthony RV, Rigano S, Parker TA, de Vrijer B, Ferrazzi E, et al. Fetal hypertension and abnormal Doppler velocimetry in an ovine model of in-trauterine growth restriction. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2005;192(1):272-9.
[62] Julian CG, Vargas E, Browne VA, Wilson MJ, Bigham AW, Rodriguez C, et al. Potential role for elevated maternal enzymatic antioxidant status in andean protection against altitude-associated SGA. J Mater Fetal Neonatal Med Off J Eur Assoc Perinat Med Fed Asia Ocean Perinat Soc Int Soc Perinat Obstet 2012;25(8):1233-40.
[63] Dilworth MR, Sibley CP. Review: transport across the placenta of mice and women. Placenta 2013;34(Suppl.):S34-9.
[64] Carmeliet P, Mackman N, Moons L, Luther T, Gressens P, Van Vlaenderen I, et al. Role of tissue factor in embryonic blood vessel development. Nature 1996;383(6595):73-5.
[65] Carmeliet P, Ferreira V, Breier G, Pollefeyt S, Kieckens L, Gertsenstein M, et al. Abnormal blood vessel development and lethality in embryos lacking a single VEGF allele. Nature 1996;380(6573):435-9.
[66] Constancia M, Hemberger M, Hughes J, Dean W, Ferguson-Smith A, Fundele R, et al. Placental-specific IGF-II is a major modulator of placental and fetal growth. Nature 2002;417(6892):945-8.
[67] Kusinski LC, Stanley JL, Dilworth MR, Hirt CJ, Andersson IJ, Renshall LJ, et al. eNOS knockout mouse as a model of fetal growth restriction with an impaired uterine artery function and placental transport phenotype. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 2012;303(1):R86-93.
[68] Dilworth MR, Kusinski LC, Baker BC, Renshall LJ, Greenwood SL, Sibley CP, et al. Defining fetal growth restriction in mice: a standardized and clinically relevant approach. Placenta 2011;32(11):914-6.
[69] Mehta V, Abi-Nader KN, Carr D, Wallace J, Coutelle C, Waddington SN, et al. Monitoring for potential adverse effects of prenatal gene therapy: use of large animal models with relevance to human application. Methods Mol Biol 2012;891:291-328.
[70] Baldwin J. In: Cartwright AC, Matthews BR, editors. Reproductive and developmental toxicity. Informa Healthcare USA Inc; 2009. p. 429-40.
[71] Kilkenny C, Browne WJ, Cuthill IC, Emerson M, Altman DG. Improving bioscience research reporting: the ARRIVE guidelines for reporting animal research. PLoS Biol 2010;8(6):e1000412.
[72] David AL, Torondel B, Zachary I, Wigley V, Abi-Nader K, Mehta V, et al. Local delivery of VEGF adenovirus to the uterine artery increases vasorelaxation and uterine blood flow in the pregnant sheep. Gene Ther 2008;15(19): 1344-50.
[73] Mehta V, Abi-Nader KN, Peebles DM, Benjamin E, Wigley V, Torondel B, et al. Long-term increase in uterine blood flow is achieved by local overexpression of VEGF-A(165) in the uterine arteries of pregnant sheep. Gene Ther 2012;19(9):925-35.
[74] Mehta V, Abi-Nader KN, Shangaris P, Shaw SW, Filippi E, Benjamin E, et al. Local over-expression of VEGF-DDeltaNDeltaC in the uterine arteries of pregnant sheep results in long-term changes in uterine artery contractility and angiogenesis. PLoS One 2014;9(6):e100021.
[75] Carr DJ, Aitken RP, Milne JS, David AL, Wallace JM. Fetoplacental biometry and umbilical artery Doppler velocimetry in the overnourished adolescent model of fetal growth restriction. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2012;207(2). 141 e6-141 e15.
8 A.M. Swanson, A.L. David / Placenta xxx (20Í5) Í—8
[76] Carr DJ, Wallace JM, Aitken RP, Milne JS, Mehta V, Martin JF, et al. Uteroplacental adenovirus vascular endothelial growth factor gene therapy increases fetal growth velocity in growth-restricted sheep pregnancies. Hum Gene Ther 2014;25(4):375—84.
[77] Klinger S, Turgeon B, Levesque K, Wood GA, Aagaard-Tillery KM, Meloche S. Loss of Erk3 function in mice leads to intrauterine growth restriction, pulmonary immaturity, and neonatal lethality. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2009;106(39):16710—5.
[78] Tanaka M, Natori M, Ishimoto H, Miyazaki T, Kobayashi T, Nozawa S. Experimental growth retardation produced by transient period of uteroplacental ischemia in pregnant Sprague-Dawley rats. AmJ Obstet Gynecol 1994;171(5): 1231—4.
[79] Benediktsson R, Lindsay RS, Noble J, Seckl JR, Edwards CR. Glucocorticoid exposure in utero: new model for adult hypertension. Lancet 1993;341(8841):339—41.
[80] Nassar AH, Masrouha KZ, Itani H, Nader KA, Usta IM. Effects of sildenafil in nomega-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester-induced intrauterine growth restriction in a rat model. Am J Perinatol 2012;29(6):429—34.
[81] Ravishankar V, Buhimschi CS, Booth CJ, Bhandari V, Norwitz E, Copel J, et al. Fetal nucleated red blood cells in a rat model of intrauterine growth restriction induced by hypoxia and nitric oxide synthase inhibition. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2007;196(5). 482 e1—482 e8.
[82] de Grauw TJ, Myers RE, Scott WJ. Fetal growth retardation in rats from different levels of hypoxia. Biol Neonate 1986;49(2):85—9.
[83] Schwartz JE, Kovach A, Meyer J, McConnell C, Iwamoto HS. Brief, intermittent hypoxia restricts fetal growth in Sprague-Dawley rats. Biol Neonate 1998;73(5):313—9.
[84] Tapanainen PJ, Bang P, Wilson K, Unterman TG, Vreman HJ, Rosenfeld RG. Maternal hypoxia as a model for intrauterine growth retardation: effects on insulin-like growth factors and their binding proteins. Pediatr Res 1994;36(2): 152—8.
[85] Woodall SM, Breier BH, Johnston BM, Gluckman PD. A model of intrauterine growth retardation caused by chronic maternal undernutrition in the rat: effects on the somatotrophic axis and postnatal growth. J Endocrinol 1996;150(2):231—42.
[86] Jones CT, Parer JT. The effect of alterations in placental blood flow on the growth of and nutrient supply to the fetal guinea-pig. J Physiol 1983;343: 525—37.
[87] Tolcos M, Rees S. Chronic placental insufficiency in the fetal guinea pig affects neurochemical and neuroglial development but not neuronal numbers in the brainstem: a new method for combined stereology and immunohistochem-istry. J Comp Neurol 1997;379(1):99-112.
[88] Rosati P, Exacoustos C, Puggioni GF, Mancuso S. Growth retardation in pregnancy: experimental model in the rabbit employing electrically induced thermal placental injury. Int J Exp Pathol 1995;76(3):179-81.
[89] Montoudis A, Simoneau L, Brissette L, Forest JC, Savard R, Lafond J. Impact of a cholesterol enriched diet on maternal and fetal plasma lipids and fetal deposition in pregnant rabbits. Life Sci 1999;64(26):2439-50.
[90] Kliegman RM. Alterations of fasting glucose and fat metabolism in intra-uterine growth-retarded newborn dogs. Am J Physiol 1989;256(3 Pt 1): E380-5.
[91] Bauer R, Walter B, Brandl U. Intrauterine growth restriction improves cerebral O2 utilization during hypercapnic hypoxia in newborn piglets. J Physiol 2007;584(Pt 2):693-704.
[92] Phillips ID, Anthony RV, Simonetta G, Owens JA, Robinson JS, McMillen IC. Restriction of fetal growth has a differential impact on fetal prolactin and prolactin receptor mRNA expression. J Neuroendocrinol 2001;13(2): 175-81.
[93] Allison BJ, Brain KL, Niu Y, Cross CM, Itani N, Kane AD, et al. Antioxidants prevent intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) and cardiac dysfunction in chronically-hypoxic fetal sheep. Reprod Sci 2013;20:63A-4A.
[94] He ZX, Wu DQ, Sun ZH, Tan ZL, Qiao JY, Ran T, et al. Protein or energy restriction during late gestation alters fetal growth and visceral organ mass: an evidence of intrauterine programming in goats. Animal Reprod Sci 2013;137(3-4):177-82.
[95] Walton AH. The maternal effects on growth and conformation in shire horse-shetland pony crosses. Proc R Soc Lond 1938;125(840):311-35.
[96] Li C, McDonald TJ, Wu G, Nijland MJ, Nathanielsz PW. Intrauterine growth restriction alters term fetal baboon hypothalamic appetitive peptide balance. J Endocrinol 2013;217(3):275-82.
[97] Roberts VH, Rasanen JP, Novy MJ, Frias A, Louey S, Morgan TK, et al. Restriction of placental vasculature in a non-human primate: a unique model to study placental plasticity. Placenta 2012;33(1):73-6.
[98] Myers RE, Hill DE, Holt AB, Scott RE, Mellits ED, Cheek DB. Fetal growth retardation produced by experimental placental insufficiency in the rhesus monkey. I. Body weight, organ size. Biol Neonate 1971;18(5):379-94.
