Scholarly article on topic 'HIV behavioural interventions targeted towards older adults: a systematic review'

HIV behavioural interventions targeted towards older adults: a systematic review Academic research paper on "Clinical medicine"

CC BY
0
0
Share paper
Academic journal
BMC Public Health
OECD Field of science
Keywords
{""}

Academic research paper on topic "HIV behavioural interventions targeted towards older adults: a systematic review"

Public Health

RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access

HIV behavioural interventions targeted towards older adults: a systematic review

Joel Negin1*, Aneuryn Rozea1 and Alexandra LC Martiniuk1,2,3

Abstract

Background: The increasing number of people living with HIV aged 50 years and older has been recognised around the world yet non-pharmacologic HIV behavioural and cognitive interventions specifically targeted to older adults are limited. Evidence is needed to guide the response to this affected group.

Methods: We conducted a systematic review of the available published literature in MEDLINE, Embase and the Education Resources Information Center. A search strategy was defined with high sensitivity but low specificity to identify behavioural interventions with outcomes in the areas of treatment adherence, HIV testing uptake, increased HIV knowledge and uptake of prevention measures. Data from relevant articles were extracted into excel. Results: Twelve articles were identified all of which originated from the Americas. Eight of the interventions were conducted among older adults living with HIV and four for HIV-negative older adults. Five studies included control groups. Of the included studies, four focused on general knowledge of HIV, three emphasised mental health and coping, two focused on reduced sexual risk behaviour, two on physical status and one on referral for care. Only four of the studies were randomised controlled trials and seven - including all of the studies among HIV-negative older adults - did not include controls at all. A few of the studies conducted statistical testing on small samples of 16 or 11 older adults making inference based on the results difficult. The most relevant study demonstrated that using telephone-based interventions can reduce risky sexual behaviour among older adults with control reporting 3.24 times (95% CI 1.79-5.85) as many occasions of unprotected sex at follow-up as participants. Overall however, few of the articles are sufficiently rigorous to suggest broad replication or to be considered representative and applicable in other settings.

Conclusions: More evidence is needed on what interventions work among older adults to support prevention, adherence and testing. More methodological rigourised needed in the studies targeting older adults. Specifically, including control groups in all studies is needed as well as sufficient sample size to allow for statistical testing. Addition of specific bio-marker or validated behavioural or cognitive outcomes would also strengthen the studies.

Keywords: Older adults, HIV, Interventions, Systematic review, Effectiveness

Background

HIV prevalence among those aged 50 years of age and older has been rising over the past few years. In the US, in 2005, 25% of those infected with HIV were older than 50 years of age [1] and recent estimates have noted that around 50% of people living with HIV will be older than 50 by 2015 [2]. The number of adults aged 50 years and older living with HIV in the US grew by 14% a year between 2004 and 2007 [3]. Articles have highlighted the

* Correspondence: joel.negin@sydney.edu.au

1Sydney Schoolof Public Health, University of Sydney, Edward Ford Building (A27), Sydney, NSW, Australia

Fulllist of author information is available at the end of the article

Bio Med Central

HIV and ageing phenomenon in New York [4], London [5], Italy [6] and Australia [7]. The increase has been seen partly due to widespread treatment access [3]. The ageing trend has been increasingly recognised in sub-Saharan Africa where the majority of HIV infections occur [8-11].

The increasing trend of ageing is not only the result of longer survival due to treatment; older adults accounted for 15% of new cases of HIV in the US in 2005 [12]. Western European data reveals that 12.9% of newly reported cases of HIV infection in 2007 were among peopled aged 50 and older compared to 10.4% in 2003 [13]. The

© 2014 Negin et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.

percentage of older adults among new infections in Eastern Europe has doubled over the same time frame [13].

The term "older adults" is used to describe those aged 50 years and older. It is acknowledged that in many countries, people in this age group would not be considered old or elderly. In Australia for example, most studies on the elderly focus on those aged 65 years and above or even 70 [14]. The reasons the 50 years cut off point is used here is because the majority of HIV surveillance and reporting over the first two decades of the HIV response has only covered those aged 15-49 [15-17] as well as the accelerated ageing of HIV infected adults compared to uninfected adults [18].

Older adults remain sexually active well into advanced ages and condom use rates among older adults are low [19,20]. In addition, testing rates among older adults are also lower: fewer than 15% of Americans aged over 45 years have been tested for HIV compared to 44% of all adults

[21] and late presentation for care is also more common

[22]. Older adults - particularly older women - are at greater physiological risk for HIV transmission [23,24]. Those aged 50 and older might also enter into new relationships in which unprotected sex is more likely given the absence of pregnancy concerns [23].

When examined, HIV knowledge amongst older adults has been variable; while some exhibit adequate knowledge many do not consider themselves to be at risk as HIV is considered an illness of younger people [25]. Surveys of HIV positive older women have suggested that insufficient HIV prevention information contributes to risk taking behaviours [26]. Because of this, there have been many urgent calls for prevention messaging and specific HIV programs targeted to older people [23,27-30] rather than simply the application of strategies designed for younger people [31]. This call has extended beyond developed countries to a number of countries in Africa [32,33].

Strengthening the argument for research focussed on HIV positive older adults are the specific problems faced by this cohort [34]. Older HIV positive adults face the additional burden of physical and psychological comor-bidities [35] and accelerated senescence [36]. Concurrently, HIV positive older adults experience the double stigma of illness and ageism while having fewer support mechanisms from family, friends and community [37].

Given this situation, a number of academics have lamented the paucity of specific studies conducted among older adults with regard to HIV prevention [38], testing, adherence [39] and other social and behavioural areas [40] for older adults with HIV. There are hypotheses of what would help treatment adherence or the effectiveness of prevention education among older adults including nutrition, mental stimulation, physical activity and better training among physicians [41] but evidence regarding these approaches is patchy and few translated

into programmatic use. Orel and colleagues [42] found that in 2004, 15 US States had HIV-related educational materials that were specifically targeted to older adults yet limited evidence is available on their impact on raising awareness and preventing new infections.

The literature provides reviews of the available evidence on HIV behavioural interventions targeted to a range of other affected groups including sex workers [43,44], children [45], men who have sex with men [46], drug users [47] and in occupational settings [48]. Based on these reviews and others, there is mixed evidence on what constitutes effective HIV prevention interventions. Peer education interventions have been found to have some positive impact on risk behaviour in some settings [49] but not others [11]. Routine opt-out testing protocols have demonstrated increased HIV testing uptake in some settings [50]. Internet and text message interventions have shown some positive impact [51,52].

Yet no compilation of evidence exists for older adults despite the recognised trend of an ageing HIV cohort globally. This paper systematically reviews the available published evidence on non-pharmacologic HIV behavioural interventions specifically targeted to older adults with a specific emphasis on treatment adherence, HIV testing uptake, increased HIV knowledge, reduced risk behaviour as well as social and physical support.

Methods

The systematic review adheres to the PRISMA guidelines. Searches were conducted on 6 February 2012 and again on 4 June 2012 in MEDLINE, Embase and the Education Resources Information Center (ERIC). A search strategy was defined with high sensitivity but low specificity. The search strategy consisted of free-text and Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) terms. Search terms for older adults included the following: "elderly", "older adults", "aged", "ageing", "geriatric", "mature adults" and "senior citizen". The terms HIV, AIDS and HIV/AIDS were included. Additional search terms to identify interventions or trials included "intervention", "trial", "evaluation", "intervention studies", "randomized controlled trials", "evaluation studies", "program evaluation" and "prevention", "testing" and "adherence" to ensure capture of relevant articles. Between each of the three categories of terms, an "AND" term was included so that only articles including information on HIV and older adults and relevant interventions were included in the results. Additionally, references of identified publications and published reviews were hand searched for potential additional relevant articles.

There were no restrictions on language or year of publication or country. We included studies that reported specifically on those aged 50 years and older or that reported age groups in which the majority of respondents

were in that age group (i.e. 45+). Studies that included participants aged, for example, 25-52 were excluded if there was no specific sub-group reporting on those aged 50 and older or in which a majority of respondents were aged 50 and older.

The inclusion criterion of the review was the search for non-pharmacologic, non-biological, behavioural and cognitive interventions. We excluded studies that evaluated treatment efficacy among older adults and included those that focused on interventions in the areas of prevention, adherence, testing, care and support. We were particularly interested in studies that demonstrated outcomes in treatment adherence, HIV testing uptake, increased HIV knowledge, reduced risk behaviour (related to sexual behaviour or injecting drug use in particular) as well as social and physical support.

In the first review round, two reviewers (JN, AR) independently scrutinised the list of article titles and eliminated the clearly non-relevant citations. Another round of exclusions using abstracts of those articles deemed potentially relevant based on titles was conducted and the final selection was based on the full text of potentially relevant articles. In cases of disagreement, a third reviewer (AM) examined the articles. Results and inclusion were discussed until consensus was reached among all three reviewers. Figure 1 outlines the number of studies included at each stage of the review process.

Data were then extracted from each relevant study into an excel spreadsheet. Extracted information included year, location of study, brief description, study type, sample size, study population, review of methods, primary outcome measure and focus topic of the study. Major themes were identified in the relevant studies. The study adheres to the PRISMA guidelines for systematic reviews.

Results

After removing duplicates, the search revealed 1229 articles. After a review of titles and then abstracts, ten articles met study criteria. An addition two articles were identified through searching reference lists and were included in the review providing twelve articles in total.

All twelve of the included studies originated from the Americas: two from Brazil and the rest from the United States. Eight of the interventions were conducted among older adults living with HIV and four among HIVnegative older adults (Table 1). Five studies included control groups.

Of the included studies, none were focused on improving treatment adherence and none had increased HIV testing uptake as an outcome measure. The four articles conducted among HIV-negative participants aimed to improve general HIV knowledge to facilitate HIV prevention. Within the studies among HIV-positive participants, the main outcome measure of Lovejoy and colleagues [53]

Figure 1 Selection of manuscripts for systematic review of behavioural HIV interventions targeted to older adults.

and Illa and colleagues [54] articles was reduced sexual risk behavior. The three Heckman et al. articles [35,37,55] focused on mental health and coping assessments while the two Souza et al. papers [36,56] emphasized physical status and strength. Improved referral for care was the outcome measure of the last relevant article [57].

The included studies do highlight areas for action in developing prevention and adherence interventions specifically for older adults. With respect to improving knowledge, Rose demonstrated that delivery of an age-specific AIDS education program was effective in improving HIV knowledge (p < 0.001) and perceptions of susceptibility (p < 0.01) among older HIV-negative Americans compared to a control group not receiving the education program [25]. While Orel and colleagues [58] and Altschuler and colleagues [59] both showed that education sessions improved HIV-related knowledge among older adults, Small's workshop did not have a significant impact [60].

Article

Focus area

Participants

Study design

Intervention

Control group (Y/N)

Measure

Results

Summary

Among HIV-Negative Older Adults

Small2009 [60]

Orelet al. 2010 [58]

Knowledge Individuals <

50 years and older N = 50

Purposive sampling USA

Knowledge 11 participants of 89 aged 60 and older completed both questionnaires N = 11 USA

Altschuler et al. 2004 [59]

Rose ' [25]

Knowledge Individuals aged >60 recruited at senior citizen mealsites USA

Pre-intervention N=458

Post-intervention N = 318

Both quantitative and qualitative data were gathered during each session and included a pre-survey and immediate post-37-item-survey, a focus group, and an HIV educationalcurriculum.

Before and after questionnaires

Knowledge Adults aged 50 years and older USA N=40

Verbal feedback after educationalprogram

Pre and post-test cross-sectional survey

Four HIV education No

training sessions each lasting three hours covering the following topics: (a) Introduction and Overview, (b) Identifying Myths and Stereotypes, (c) HIV Facts, and (d) Provision of Resources.

"No One is Immune Project" No -six-hour education and prevention workshop held at senior centre. Post-test questionnaire administered immediately after workshop.

3 hour educational program. Curriculum includes overview, myths and stereotypes, facts and resources.

20-30 minute age-specific AIDS education program delivered at mealsite and educational pamphlet. Consisted of statistics and facts about HIV, prevention measures and case studies of elderly people with HIV. Post-test administered immediately following education program.

Interest in HIV prevention and education (composite of two questions)

Substantive HIV knowledge (composite of 15 questions)

45-item HIV/AIDS

Knowledge

Questionnaire

Group feedback on HIV awareness, HIV perceptions and ability to speak to health care providers

Questionnaire measured HIV knowledge and perceptions of susceptibility to HIV (Likert scales)

HIV knowledge was not significantly (p = .273) higher in the posttest (mean = 10.92) than in the pretest (mean = 10.32)

Increase in % answering correct

• HIV can be spread by mosquitoes (48 to 98)

• you cannot get HIV when getting a tattoo (25 to 78)

• women are always tested for HIV during their pap smears (12 to 100)

• No data provided on overallchanges in scores

Participants identified learning that HIV was relevant to their lives; feeling empowered to speak up to their health care providers; positive impression being able to discuss a taboo topic.

Significant increase in totalknowledge about AIDS (p< 0.001), perceived susceptibility (p < 0.01) and perceived severity (p < 0.001)

Substantive knowledge about HIV and AIDS remained low among respondents, and there was no significant change in knowledge after the administration of the modified curriculum

Workshop increased knowledge of HIV among older adults

Qualitative results suggest that education program can help individuals discuss HIV with partners.

Age specific education program significantly increased HIV-related knowledge at senior citizen mealsites

Among HIV-Positive Older Adults

Lovejoy et al. 2011 [53]

behaviour

HIV-infected adults 45-plus years old who reported engaging in at least one occasion of unprotected sex in the 3 months prior to enrolment N = 100 USA

3 arms - 4-sessions (N = 39), 1 session (N = 38) or nothing/ control (N = 23).

Randomised controlled trial

Telephone delivered motivational interviewing (Ml) (client-focused and directive form of counselling) to reduce risky sexual behaviour

Yes(N =2

Ruiz and Ka merman 2010 [57]

Referral for care

HIV-positive patients aged >60 years N = 57 USA

Descriptive

Functional screening for No detection of comorbidities and referral for further care if failed in 3 or more domains

Illa et al. 2010 Risk [54] behaviour

HIV-positive, 45 or older, sexually active in last 12 months

N = 241 (149 intervention group and 92 in contra group) USA

Randomised controlled trial

Project ROADMAP Yes

(re-educating older adult in maintaining AIDS prevention).

ntervention group: educational brochure and four psycho-educational group sessions designed for HIV-positive older adults. Sessions focused on information, motivation, behavioural skills and risk reduction behaviours. Control: educational brochure only.

3) Episodes of

unprotected sex in past 3 months

Referrals for comorbid conditions

Sexual risk (number of partners, partner HIV status, sexual acts, condom use)

HIV knowledge (33 item measure) Sexual self-efficacy

Participants in the 4-session Ml arm enc in the fewest occasions of unprotected sex at 3 and 6 month follow-up. Controls had on average 3.24 times as many occasions of unprotected sex (95% CI 1.79-5.85). Furthermore, 1-session Ml participants had four times as many unprotected sex acts as 4-session Ml participants at 3-month (OR = 3.98 [2.38-6.67]) and 6-month (OR = 4.39 [2.56-7.46]) follow-up.

17 patients were referred due to problems in multiple domains including cognitive dysfunction (10), problems in daily living (8), nutritional issues (6), depression (5), and mobility (5)

nconsistent condom use with partners of negative or unknown serostatus reduced from 9% at baseline to 1.3% at 6 month follow-up among intervention group (p = .003); reduced from 4% to 3% with control group (p = .999)

Four sessions of telephone-delivered Ml reduces sexual risk behaviour among HIV-positive older adults

Screening for comorbidities among HIV-positive older adults can facilitate referral for further care likely to improve quality of care and outcomes

Group psycho-educational sessions reduced unprotected sexual acts with partners of unknown or negative serostatus

Ln Ln 00 O

Heckman Coping

et al. 2001

HIV-positive individuals aged 50 years and older attending AIDS service organizations

Pilot pre- and post-test cohort study

Coping improvement group intervention

Heckman Coping

et al. 2006

HIV-positive individuals aged 50 years and older recruited from AIDS service organizations with diagnosis of depression or dysthymia N = 90 USA

Randomised controlled trial with delayed treatment contra Embedded cohort study Assessed pre, post (within 1 week of completion) and at3 months

12, 90 minute sessions, telephone delivered weekly coping improvement group intervention to reduce psychological distress 1) mmediate treatment (n = 44) 2) Delayed treatment (control) (n =46)

Severity of HIV-related Life Problem Scale

Ways of coping Questionnaire Functional assessment of HIV Infection Scale

Provision of Soda relations

Geriatric depression scale (GDS) Symptom checklist 90-revised (SCL-90-R)

HIV-related life-stressor burden scale UCLA Loneliness Scale (10-item)

The Ways of Coping Checklist (WOCC)

Coping self-efficacy Scale

ncreased social wellbeing (2.20 to 2.41, p < 0.05)

Marginal non-significant change in coping (p < 0.10)

Marginal non-significant decrease in stress associated with AIDS-related loss and health concerns (p <0.10)

Marginal non-significant increase in support from friends (p < 0.10)

ntervention group reported fewer psychological symptoms (p = 0.05), less life stressor burden (p = 0.058), less use of avoidant coping strategies (p = 0.05) and marginally higher levels of coping self-efficacy (p = 0.10) compared to controls with no effect on depressive symptoms, loneliness or use of engagement coping Within cohorts IG: significant decrease in depressive symptoms (p < 0.003) psychological symptoms (p < 0.001), life-stressor burden (p < 0.03) and avoidance coping (p < 0.04) at 3 months Delayed group: significant decrease in psychological symptoms (p < 0.03), life stressor burdens (p< 0.001), loneliness (p < 0.03) and greater coping self-efficacy (p < 0.04) following intervention

Group sessions focusing on coping strategies had limited impact on coping and stress but increased social wellbeing among HIV-positive older adults

Telephone delivered coping group sessions among HIV-positive people with depression were effective in reducing psychological symptoms and stress

NJ k p

Ln Ln 00 O

Heckman Coping

et al. 2011

HIV-positive individuals aged 50 years or older with Beck Depression nventory-ll score 10 or more and Modified mini-mental state examination score of 75 or greater. N = 295 USA

Randomised controlled trial 3 arms

1) 12 90 minute sessions face-to-face coping improvement (FFCI) group intervention (n = 104)

2) 12 session interpersona support group (IPSG) intervention (n = 105)

3) Individual therapy upon request (ITUR) contra

(n = 86). Subjects had access to standard psychosocial services available in the community.

Souza et al. Physical Subjects HIV+, older

2008 [56] support than 60 (Mean 65.6+/-2.9), sedentary at baseline. 3 subsequently excluded due to >3/12 absence from training program N = 11.

All subjects medica able to complete training and not using cortico- or anabolic steroids Brazil

Souza et al. Physical Subjects HIV+, age > =

2011 [36] support 60 (M = 64.4 +/- 3.0) Ave. 9 year history of HIV, recruited at Hospital in Sao Paulo, Brazil N = 11 with 21 controls All subjects medically able to complete training and not using cortico- or anabolic steroids

Prospective Case series study

Controlled tria

1 year resistance training program 4 exercises targeting major muscle groups 3 sets 8-12 reps at light, mod and heavy resistance respectively 2 sessions/week, one year

Progressive resistance exercise 2 sessions per week for 1 year.

Five exercises utilised major muscle groups

3 sets 12/10/8 repetitions at sub-maximum load

Geriatric Depression Screening Scale

Completed using audio-computer assisted self interviews (A-CASI)

Anthropometric indices: Body mass, circumferences and skin folds Body composition (DEXA) Strength and functional tests: Sub-maximum weight lifted Two functional tests performed every 4 months assessing walking speed, and sit-to-stand performance.

Both FFCI and IPSG participants reported fewer depressive symptoms than controls post-intervention, 4- and 8-month follow-up. This effect was not always statistically significant (p's< 0.01-0.1). IPSG reported fewer depressive symptoms compared to control.

Effect size greater for subset of participants with mild, mod and severe depression at baseline

No significant change in weight Strength improvements of between

74-97% (p's = 0.003-0.021)

Functional tests: decreased times for sit-stand (2.00 to 1.57 s, p = 0.003) and walking 2.4 m (9.25 to 6.58 s, p = 0.003)

An age-appropriate coping improvement group intervention was effective in reducing depressive symptoms in HIV + older adults. The effect was more pronounced amongst subjects suffering greater levels of depressive symptoms.

Following one year of progressive resistance training HIV positive older adults showed significant improvements in strength and functional capacity, no changes in body composition and improved

immunological indices.

Ln Ln 00 O

Strength and functional tests:

Sub-maximum load monitored bi-monthly Functional test of walk and sit-stand speeds. Anthropometric and metabolic indices: Weight; BMI Lipid and glycaemic profiles (values registered in clinical record immediately before and after training program)

Although weaker at baseline, HIV + subjects increased weight lifted from 1.52 to 2.33 times baseline, a significantly greater improvement than controls (1.21-1.48, p<0.01) HIV+ lighter, significantly lower BM (p = 0.007 pre and p = 0.004 post) Faster at walking tests (significant, p = 0.036 pre-, not significant post-training). HIV + significantly faster at sit-to-stand after training than controls (p = 0.005) Fasting BSL significantly improved in both groups (p's = 0.027-0.037).

Progressive resistance exercise training produced increased strength and functional gains in older adults living with HIV, with gains superior to those seen in age-matched HIV-controls. An effect was also seen on metabolic indices.

Other interventions targeted HIV-infected older adults to reduce risk behaviour. The ROADMAP (Reeducating Older Adult in Maintaining AIDS Prevention) project ran group educational sessions to reduce high-risk sexual behaviours [54]. After sessions that included practicing condom use skills and role playing condom negotiation, participants in the intervention group (N = 149) reported reduced inconsistent condom use (9% at baseline to 1% at 6 month follow-up; p = 0.003) compared with the control group (N = 92) (4% at baseline to 3% at follow-up; p = .0999). Another study used telephone-based interventions to reduce risky sexual behaviour with controls reporting on average 3.24 times (95% CI 1.79-5.85) as many occasions of unprotected sex at follow-up [53].

Supporting older adults to cope with HIV infection was the focus of three papers [35,37,55]. Heckman and colleagues reported that group sessions with trained facilitators that included a focus on coping mechanisms and how to deal with stress are effective in reducing depressive symptoms in HIV-positive older adults (p values ranging from 0.01 to 0.1 for variety of measures; see Table 1) [35].

Weekly resistance exercise training sessions trialed in Sao Paulo, Brazil [36,56], among HIV-positive older adults, produced increased strength and functional gains superior to those seen in age-matched HIV-negative controls. Those receiving the intervention (N = 11) increased weight lifted compared to controls (N = 21) (p < 0.01) and were faster at sit-to-stand after training (p = 0.005) [36].

Discussion and conclusion

This systematic review of behavioural HIV interventions specifically targeted to older adults reveals the absolute paucity of published literature on this topic despite the increases in the number of people living with HIV aged 50 years and older and the increasing prevalence in this group globally. Though there have been many calls for more evidence that specifically address the vulnerabilities and characteristics of older adults, only twelve articles were found that included some evaluation of an intervention for this population. Limited conclusions can be drawn due to the small sample of relevant studies. The diversity of behavioural and cognitive interventions applied in the studies limits the ability to generalise from the results available; a number of interventions focused on knowledge building, others on sexual behaviour and others on coping.

Only four of the studies were randomised controlled trials and seven - including all of the studies among HIV-negative older adults - did not include controls at all. A few of the studies conducted statistical testing on small samples of 16 or 11 older adults making inference based on the results difficult. A number of the studies -

especially those among HIV-negative individuals focused on general HIV awareness and interest as opposed to behaviour change. More methodological rigour is needed in the studies targeting older adults. Specifically, including control groups in all studies is needed as well as sufficient sample size to allow for statistical testing. Addition of specific bio-marker or validated behavioural or cognitive outcomes would also strengthen the studies.

The majority of articles identified from the searches and ultimately excluded from this review describe behaviours of older adults rather than evaluating an intervention [34]. For example, there were articles that described specific intervention projects targeted to older adults - for example the Florida Senior HIV Intervention Project -but which did not provide any evidence of success or evaluation of the program [61]. Other papers did not report on those aged 50 and older. For example, one paper provided data for the age group 30-59 but was not included in the review because it did not report on older adults specifically [62].

Despite the limited number of papers providing evidence on this topic, some lessons do emerge from the review. Due to concerns over stigma and the perception of being low risk, researchers have suggested approaches for older adults through the lens of sexuality and sexual health rather than HIV directly [58]. Providing information on, for example, the impact of medications on sexuality may provide an appropriate time to discuss safe sex and HIV.

Though there is an erroneous ageist assumption that older people are not able to make behaviour changes [63], a number of ideas were expressed as possible avenues to reach older adults with HIV services including using older adults as peer educators [42] and providing training in sexuality counselling to social workers working with this age group [40]. Others advocate for the increased use of internet and mobile phone based HIV programs to reach the elderly who might be uncomfortable discussing HIV in more public settings [64]. A number of authors called for more education of physicians on the topic to ensure that HIV counselling and also testing are carried out among older adults [65,66].

This systematic review has a number of limitations. The review focused specifically on interventions reporting outcomes among older adults and therefore might have missed interventions designed for adults of all ages that are effective among older adults. The review only included published papers documenting interventions that had been evaluated thus eliminating a large set of publications that only describe interventions. The review is also subject to publication bias and selective reporting as is common in systematic reviews.

The review only searched for studies specifically on HIV. There are a number of other studies on medication

adherence generally among older adults [67-69] or on sexual health interventions that might be relevant to HIV that were not included here.

Given the trends within the HIV community, much more rigorous evidence is needed on how best to provide services for those aged 50 years and older. A number of interventions were mentioned in articles, but without evidence of impact, suggesting that there are opportunities for evaluations to add to the base of knowledge in this area [61]. Some particular understudied challenges for older adults include: 1) through which channels is it best to reach older adults; 2) what types of messaging are most appropriate for this population; and 3) what content resonates with older adults. Interventions might be targeted to older adults themselves or to health professionals and other providers of services to older adults. Specific evaluated interventions are needed in the areas of testing, supporting adherence, reducing risky sexual behaviours are all areas where the evidence base is currently insufficient. More operational research is needed to scrutinise the "how" of service delivery for older adults [70] and how to provide it at scale. The other major research challenge will be building an evidence base for older adults living in low and middle income countries where very little currently exists. The American studies are likely not to be applicable to other parts of the world and therefore new research will be critical as the HIV cohort in Africa and Asia ages into the future.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Authors' contributions

JN conceived of the study. JN and AR conducted the initialreviews of articles and AM served as arbitrator. JN and AR wrote the first draft and AM provided reviews. Allauthors read and approved the finalmanuscript.

Acknowledgements

JN was partially supported by an Australian NationalHealth and Medical Research CouncilCapacity Building Grant. AM was funded by a Fellowship from the University of Sydney, Australia.

Author details

1Sydney Schoolof Public Health, University of Sydney, Edward Ford Building (A27), Sydney, NSW, Australia. 2Dalla Lana Schoolof Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. 3George Institute for GlobalHealth, Sydney, Australia.

Received: 25 January 2013 Accepted: 20 May 2014 Published: 26 May 2014

References

1. Gebo KA: HIV infection in older people. BMJ 2009, 338:b1460.

2. Effros RB, Fletcher CV, Gebo K, Halter JB, Hazzard WR, Horne FM, Huebner RE, Janoff EN, Justice AC, Kuritzkes D, Nayfield SG, Plaeger SF, Schmader KE, Ashworth JR, Campanelli C, Clayton CP, Rada B, Woolard NF, High KP: Aging and infectious diseases: workshop on HIV infection and aging: what is a known and future research direction. Clin Infect Dis 2008,47(4):542-553.

3. Justice AC: HIV and aging: time for a new paradigm. Curr HIV/AIDS Rep 2010, 7(2):69-76.

4. Shippy RA, Karpiak SE: The aging HIV/AIDS population: fragile social networks. Aging Ment Health 2005, 9(3):246-254.

5. Elford J, Ibrahim F, Bukutu C, Anderson J: Over fifty and living with HIV in London. Sex Transm Infect 2008, 84(6):468-472.

6. Orchi N, Balzano R, Scognamiglio P, Navarra A, De Carli G, Elia P, Grisetti S, Sampaolesi A, Giuliani M, De Filippis A, Puro V, Ippolito G, Girardi E, SENDIH group: Ageing with HIV: newly diagnosed older adults in Italy. AIDS Care 2008, 20(4):419-425.

7. Pitts M, Grierson J, Misson S: Growing older with HIV: a study of health, social and economic circumstances for people Living with HIV in Australia over the age of 50 years. ADS Patient Care STDS 2005, 19(7):460-465.

8. Negin J, Cumming RG: HIV infection in older adults in sub-Saharan Africa: extrapolating prevalence from existing data. Bull World Health Organ 2010, 88(11):847-853.

9. Hontelez JA, Lurie MN, Newell ML, Bakker R, Tanser F, Barnighausen T, Baltussen R, de Vlas SJ: Ageing with HIV in South Africa. AIDS 2011, 25(13):1665-1667.

10. Mills EJ, Barnighausen T, Negin J: HIV and aging-preparing for the challenges ahead. N Engl J Med 2012, 366(14):1270-1273.

11. Shisana O, Human Sciences Research Council, Centre for AIDS Development Research and Evaluation, South African Medical Research Counci, National Institute for Communicable Diseases (South Africa): South African National HIV Prevalence, Incidence, Behaviour and Communication Survey, 2008: A Turning Tide Among Teenagers. Cape Town: HSRC Press; 2009.

12. Simone MJ, Appelbaum J: HIV in older adults. Geriatrics 2008, 63(12):6-12.

13. Lazarus JV, Nielsen KK: HIV and people over 50 years old in Europe. HIV Med 2010, 11 (7):479-481.

14. Cumming RG, Handelsman D, Seibel MJ, Creasey H, Sambrook P, Waite L, Naganathan V, Le Couteur D, Litchfield M: Cohort Profile: the Concord Health and Ageing in Men Project (CHAMP). Int J Epidemiol 2009, 38(2):374-378.

15. UNAIDS: AIDS at 30: nations at the crossroads. Geneva: Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS; 2011.

16. UNAIDS: Monitoring the Declaration of Commitment on HIV/AIDS: guidelines on construction of core indicators: 2010 reporting. Geneva, Switzerland: UNAIDS; 2009.

17. Demographic and Health Surveys. [http://www.measuredhs.com/]

18. Work Group for the HIV and Aging Consensus Project: Summary report from the Human Immunodeficiency Virus and Aging Consensus Project: treatment strategies for clinicians managing older individuals with the human immunodeficiency virus. J Am Geriatr Soc 2012, 60(5):974-979.

19. Lindau ST, Schumm LP, Laumann EO, Levinson W, O'Muircheartaigh CA, Waite LJ: A study of sexuality and health among older adults in the United States. N Engl J Med 2007, 357(8):762-774.

20. Schick V, Herbenick D, Reece M, Sanders SA, Dodge B, Middlestadt SE, Fortenberry JD: Sexual behaviors, condom use, and sexual health of Americans over 50: implications for sexual health promotion for older adults. J Sex Med 2010, 7(Suppl 5):315-329.

21. Akers AY, Bernstein L, Doyle J, Corbie-Smith G: Older women and HIV testing: examining the relationship between HIV testing history, age, and lifetime HIV risk behaviors. Sex Transm Dis 2008, 35(4):420-423.

22. Iwuji CC, Churchill D, Gilleece Y, Weiss HA, Fisher M: Older HIV-infected individuals present late and have a higher mortality: Brighton, UK cohort study. BMC Public Health 2013, 13:397.

23. Orel NA, Spence M, Steele J: Getting the message out to older adults: Effective HIV health education risk reduction publications. J Appl Gerontol 2005, 24(5):490-508.

24. Drew O, Sherrard J: Sexually transmitted infections in the older woman. Menopause Int 2008, 14(3):134-135.

25. Rose MA: Effect of an AIDS education program for older adults. J Community Health Nurs 1996, 13(3):141 -148.

26. Neundorfer MM, Harris PB, Britton PJ, Lynch DA: HIV-risk factors for midlife and older women. Gerontologist 2005, 45(5):617.

27. Bhavan KP, Kampalath VN, Overton ET: The aging of the HIV epidemic. Curr HIV/AIDS Rep 2008, 5(3):150-158.

28. Lovejoy TI, Heckman TG, Sikkema KJ, Hansen NB, Kochman A, Suhr JA, Garske JP, Johnson CJ: Patterns and correlates of sexual activity and condom use behavior in persons 50-plus years of age living with HIV/ AIDS. AIDS Behav 2008, 12(6):943-956.

29. Winningham A, Corwin S, Moore C, Richter D, Sargent R, Gore-Felton C: The changing age of HIV: sexual risk among older African American women living in rural communities. Prev Med 2004, 39(4):809-814.

30. Strombeck R, Levy JA: Educational strategies and interventions targeting adults age 50 and older for HIV/AIDS prevention. Res Aging 1998, 20(6):912—936.

31. UNAIDS: HIV and Aging: A Special Supplement to the UNAIDS Report on the global AIDS Epidemic Geneva, Switzerland: UNAIDS; 2013.

32. Philip-Ephraim EE, Gyuse AN, Udonwa NE, Peters EJ, Anyanechi CC: Knowledge and perception of HIV prevention through condom use among midlife and older adults in Calabar, Nigeria. West Indian Med J

2010, 59(4):429-433.

33. Negin J, Nemser B, Cumming R, Lelerai E, Ben Amor Y, Pronyk P: HIV attitudes, awareness and testing among older adults in Africa. AIDS Behav 2012, 16(1):63-68.

34. Sankar A, Nevedal A, Neufeld S, Berry R, Luborsky M: What do we know about older adults and HIV? A review of social and behavioral literature. AIDS Care 2011, 23(10):1187-1207.

35. Heckman TG, Sikkema KJ, Hansen N, Kochman A, Heh V, Neufeld S, Aids, Aging Research G: A randomized clinical trial of a coping improvement group intervention for HIV-infected older adults. J Behav Med 2011, 34(2):102-111.

36. Souza PM, Jacob-Filho W, Santarem JM, Zomignan AA, Burattini MN: Effect of progressive resistance exercise on strength evolution of elderly patients living with HIV compared to healthy controls. Clinics (Sao Paulo)

2011, 66(2):261 —266.

37. Heckman TG, Kochman A, Sikkema KJ, Kalichman SC, Masten J, Bergholte J, Catz S: A pilot coping improvement intervention for late middle-aged and older adults living with HIV/AIDS in the USA. AIDS Care 2001, 13(1):129—139.

38. Mack KA, Bland SD: HIV testing behaviors and attitudes regarding HIV/ AIDS of adults aged 50-64. Gerontologist 1999, 39(6):687-694.

39. Wutoh AK, Elekwachi O, Clarke-Tasker V, Daftary M, Powell NJ, Campusano G: Assessment and predictors of antiretroviral adherence in older HIV-infected patients. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2003, 33(Suppl 2):S106—114.

40. Williams E, Donnelly J: Older Americans and AIDS: some guidelines for prevention. Soc Work 2002, 47(2):105-111.

41. Vance DE, Burrage JW: Promoting successful cognitive aging in adults with HIV: strategies for intervention. J Gerontol Nurs 2006, 32(11):34-41.

42. Orel NA, Wright JM, Wagner J: Scarcity of HIV/AIDS risk-reduction materials targeting the needs of older adults among state departments of public health. Gerontologist 2004, 44(5):693-696.

43. Wariki WM, Ota E, Mori R, Koyanagi A, Hori N, Shibuya K: Behavioral interventions to reduce the transmission of HIV infection among sex workers and their clients in low- and middle-income countries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2012, 2:CD005272.

44. Ota E, Wariki WM, Mori R, Hori N, Shibuya K: Behavioral interventions to reduce the transmission of HIV infection among sex workers and their clients in high-income countries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011, 12:CD006045.

45. Bain-Brickley D, Butler LM, Kennedy GE, Rutherford GW: Interventions to improve adherence to antiretroviral therapy in children with HIV infection. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011, 12:CD009513.

46. Wei C, Herrick A, Raymond HF, Anglemyer A, Gerbase A, Noar SM: Social marketing interventions to increase HIV/STI testing uptake among men who have sex with men and male-to-female transgender women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011, 9:CD009337.

47. Meader N, Li R, Des Jarlais DC, Pilling S: Psychosocial interventions for reducing injection and sexual risk behaviour for preventing HIV in drug users. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2010, 1:CD007192.

48. Ojo O, Verbeek JH, Rasanen K, Heikkinen J, Isotalo LK, Mngoma N, Ruotsalainen E: Interventions to reduce risky sexual behaviour for preventing HIV infection in workers in occupational settings. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011, 12:CD005274.

49. Simoni JM, Nelson KM, Franks JC, Yard SS, Lehavot K: Are peer interventions for HIV efficacious? A systematic review. AIDS Behav 2011, 15(8):1589—1595.

50. Creek TL, Ntumy R, Seipone K, Smith M, Mogodi M, Smit M, Legwaila K, Molokwane I, Tebele G, Mazhani L, Shaffer N, Kilmarx PH: Successful introduction of routine opt-out HIV testing in antenatal care in Botswana. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2007, 45(1):102-107.

51. Kang M, Skinner R, Usherwood T: Interventions for young people in Australia to reduce HIV and sexually transmissible infections: a systematic review. Sex Health 2010, 7(2):107-128.

52. Noar SM, Black HG, Pierce LB: Efficacy of computer technology-based HIV prevention interventions: a meta-analysis. AIDS 2009, 23(1):107-115.

53. Lovejoy TI, Heckman TG, Suhr JA, Anderson T, Heckman BD, France CR: Telephone-administered motivational interviewing reduces risky sexual behavior in HIV-positive late middle-age and older adults: a pilot randomized controlled trial. AIDS Behav 2011, 15(8):1623-1634.

54. Illa L, Echenique M, Saint Jean G, Bustamante-Avellaneda V, Metsch L, Mendez-Mulet L, Eisdorfer C, Sanchez-Martinez M: Project roadmap: reeducating older adults in maintaining AIDS prevention-a secondary intervention for older HIV-positive adults. AIDS Educ Prev 2010, 22(2):138-147.

55. Heckman TG, Barcikowski R, Ogles B, Suhr J, Carlson B, Holroyd K, Garske J: A telephone-delivered coping improvement group intervention for middle-aged and older adults living with HIV/AIDS. Ann Behav Med 2006,

32(1):27-38.

56. Souza PM, Jacob-Filho W, Santarem JM, Silva AR, Li HY, Burattini MN: Progressive resistance training in elderly HIV-positive patients: does it work? Clinics (Sao Paulo) 2008, 63(5):619-624.

57. Ruiz M, Kamerman LA: Nutritional screening tools for HIV-infected patients: implications for elderly patients. J Int Assoc Physicians AIDS Care (Chic) 2010, 9(6):362-367.

58. Orel NA, Stelle C, Watson WK, Bunner BL: No one is immune: a community education partnership addressing HIV/AIDS and older adults. J Appl Gerontol 2010, 29(3):352-370.

59. Altschuler J, Katz AD, Tynan M: Developing and implementing an HIV/ AIDS educational curriculum for older adults. Gerontologist 2004, 44(1):121 —126.

60. Small LF: What older adults know about HIV/AIDS: lessons from an HIV/ AIDS education program. Educ Gerontol 2009, 36(1):26—45.

61. Agate LL, Mullins JM, Prudent ES, Liberti TM: Strategies for reaching retirement communities and aging social networks: HIV/AIDS prevention activities among seniors in South Florida. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2003, 33(Suppl 2):S238—242.

62. Wawer MJ, Sewankambo NK, Serwadda D, Quinn TC, Paxton LA, Kiwanuka N, Wabwire-Mangen F, Li C, Lutalo T, Nalugoda F, Gaydos CA, Moulton LH, Meehan MO, Ahmed S, Gray RH: Control of sexually transmitted diseases for AIDS prevention in Uganda: a randomised community trial. Rakai Project Study Group. Lancet 1999, 353(9152):525—535.

63. Coon DW, Lipman PD, Ory MG: Designing effective HIV/AIDS social and behavioral interventions for the population of those age 50 and older. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2003, 33(Suppl 2):S194—205.

64. Ybarra ML, Bull SS: Current trends in Internet- and cell phone-based HIV prevention and intervention programs. Curr HIV/AIDS Rep 2007, 4(4):201 —207.

65. Chiao EY, Ries KM, Sande MA: AIDS and the elderly. Clin Infect Dis 1999, 28(4):740—745.

66. Skiest DJ, Keiser P: Human immunodeficiency virus infection in patients older than 50 years: A survey of primary care physicians' beliefs, practices, and knowledge. Arch Fam Med 1997, 6(3):289—294.

67. Morrell RW, Park DC, Kidder DP, Martin M: Adherence to antihypertensive medications across the life span. Gerontologist 1997, 37(5):609—619.

68. McDonald-Miszczak L, Maki SA, Gould ON: Self-reported medication adherence and health status in late adulthood: the role of beliefs. Exp Aging Res 2000, 26(3):189—207.

69. Barat I, Andreasen F, Damsgaard EM: Drug therapy in the elderly: what doctors believe and patients actually do. Br J Clin Pharmacol 2001,

51 (6):615—622.

70. Herbst JH, Glassman M, Carey JW, Painter TM, Gelaude DJ, Fasula AM, Raiford JL, Freeman AE, Harshbarger C, Viall AH, Purcell DW: Operational research to improve HIV prevention in the United States. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2012, 59(5):530—536.

doi:10.1186/1471 -2458-14-507

Cite this article as: Negin et al.: HIV behavioural interventions targeted towards older adults: a systematic review. BMC Public Health 2014 14:507.